The Eleventh Circuit recently examined two insurance coverage cases involving the applicability of the pollution exclusion. In one case it held that sewage was not a pollutant, but in the other case it held that storm water was a pollutant. These cases provide guidance to policyholders who may face a pollution exclusion argument from their carrier in the Eleventh Circuit. In the case Evanston Insurance Company v. J&J Cable Construction, LLC, the Eleventh Circuit held that damage caused by a sewage leak was not barred by the pollution exclusion. (Case No. 17-11188, April 20, 2018). The court looked to a prior Alabama case that distinguished industrial waste from residential sewage. However, the Eleventh Circuit reached the opposite conclusion in the case Centro Development Corp. v. Central Mutual Insurance Company (Case No. 17-13489, April 27, 2018). There, the Eleventh Circuit found that storm water was a pollutant excluded by the policy’s pollution exclusion. The court looked to a Georgia Supreme Court case that held that a pollutant did not have to be specifically named in the policy in order for the exclusion to apply, as was the case in the Central Mutual policy. These decisions serve as a good reminder that the Eleventh Circuit will look to precedent from the state law that governs the coverage dispute. In addition, whether a pollutant is tied to industrial waste may be a determining factor for the application of the pollution exclusion in the Eleventh Circuit.
Eleventh Circuit Reaches Different Conclusions While Examining Pollution Exclusion
RELATED ARTICLES
Watershed California Decision Finds for Policyholder in COVID-19 Business Interruption Appeal
July 14, 2022 | Policyholder Protection, Property Insurance
When You Get Sued, Don’t Forget to Tell Your Insurance Company
June 1, 2022 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance
Out of Sight, But Not Out of Mind: Facts Outside the Pleadings and the Duty to Defend
October 15, 2021 | Policyholder Protection, Duty To Defend
Insurance Coverage for Emerging Contaminants
October 15, 2021 | Policyholder Protection, Environmental, Insurance
Mind the Gap: Coverage Gaps Created by Commercial General Liability Policies
October 15, 2021 | Policyholder Protection, Commercial General Liability
Watershed California Decision Finds for Policyholder in COVID-19 Business Interruption Appeal
July 14, 2022 | Policyholder Protection, Property Insurance
When You Get Sued, Don’t Forget to Tell Your Insurance Company
June 1, 2022 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance
Out of Sight, But Not Out of Mind: Facts Outside the Pleadings and the Duty to Defend
October 15, 2021 | Policyholder Protection, Duty To Defend
Insurance Coverage for Emerging Contaminants
October 15, 2021 | Policyholder Protection, Environmental, Insurance
Mind the Gap: Coverage Gaps Created by Commercial General Liability Policies
October 15, 2021 | Policyholder Protection, Commercial General Liability
This, That, and the Other: Different Insurance Policies Can Cover the Same Loss
June 21, 2021 | Policyholder Protection, Additional Insured, Insurance
Pollution and Contamination Exclusions Don’t Warrant COVID-19 BI Claim Denials
February 22, 2021 | Policyholder Protection, Claims, Policy
Tribal Property Insurance Found to Cover COVID-19 Business Interruption Losses
January 25, 2021 | Policyholder Protection, Policy, Property Insurance
Gone Phishin': How Does Insurance Apply To Business Email Compromise Losses?
December 9, 2020 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance, Cyber Insurance, Data Breach
Top 7 Opportunities and Obstacles in Negotiating Pollution Coverage
December 9, 2020 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance
Insurance Coverage for Emerging Contaminants
June 3, 2020 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance, Environmental
Will Legislation Require Coverage for COVID-19 Business Interruption Losses?
April 3, 2020 | Policyholder Protection, Policy, Insurance, Claims
Privilege and Work Product in Insurance Coverage Disputes
September 3, 2019 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance
‘Sudden and Accidental’ Discharges May Avoid the Pollution Exclusion
May 28, 2019 | Environmental, Policyholder Protection, Remediation, Commercial General Liability
‘Sudden and Accidental’ Discharges May Avoid the Pollution Exclusion
May 28, 2019 | Environmental, Policyholder Protection, Remediation, Commercial General Liability
Municipalities Beware: Inverse Condemnation Exclusions May Affect Coverage
January 17, 2019 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance, Policy
Minnesota Court of Appeals Confirms Agent Comments Can Bind Insurer
May 25, 2018 | Indiana Insurance Coverage, Policyholder Protection
Upcoming Webinar: Insurance Coverage for Opioid Litigation and Lessons for Other Types of Claims
May 17, 2018 | Claims, Webinar, Policyholder Protection
Daubert Challenge Resolves Coverage Dispute on Summary Judgment
November 3, 2017 | Indiana Insurance Coverage, Policyholder Protection
Back to School: Time to Revisit the Basic Principles of Business Interruption Coverage
August 29, 2017 | Indiana Insurance Coverage, Natural Disaster, Policyholder Protection
Is a Claimant’s Misnomer the Be-All, End-All in an Insurance Coverage Dispute?
July 13, 2017 | Indiana Insurance Coverage, Policyholder Protection
Overcoming That Sinking Feeling
March 6, 2017 | Commercial General Liability, Policyholder Protection
When the Damage is Done Are You Prepared to Litigate Against Your Insurance Company?
October 11, 2016 | Insurance, Insurance Broker Claims, Policyholder Protection
When a “Pollutant by Any Other Name” Is Not a Pollutant
May 6, 2016 | Insurance, Policy, Policyholder Protection
Join us: Insurance Considerations in Mergers and Acquisitions
March 7, 2016 | Insurance, Miscellaneous, Policyholder Protection
Sing The Jingle: Four Tips Inspired By Insurance Ads
March 3, 2016 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Barnes & Thornburg Bronze Sponsor of the 2015 ABA Women in Litigation Conference
November 20, 2015 | Claims, Insurance, Policyholder Protection
PENNSYLVANIA HIGH COURT EXPANDS CIRCUMSTANCES UNDER WHICH INSUREDS MAY SETTLE UNDERLYING CLAIMS WITHOUT INSURER CONSENT
August 26, 2015 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Five Tips: Insurance Fundamentals for In-House Counsel
July 15, 2015 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Are we seeing a revival in Michigan environmental insurance coverage?
June 5, 2015 | Insurance, Miscellaneous, Policyholder Protection
Barnes & Thornburg Represents Simon Property Group in $200 Million Summary Judgment Victory
March 18, 2015 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Eleventh Circuit Decision Epitomizes the Differing Standards of Justice Received by Insureds in State Versus Federal Courts
February 13, 2015 | Claims, Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Did the Supreme Court just make removal easier for insurance companies?
January 21, 2015 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Scott Godes quoted in, “Insurers cover fraction of costs in Catholic dioceses’ clergy abuse cases”
January 6, 2015 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Scott Godes to Present at the Comprehensive Conference on Cybersecurity Law Presented by Law Seminars International
November 20, 2014 | Cyber Insurance, Policyholder Protection
RELATED PRACTICE AREAS
Subscribe
Do you want to receive more valuable insights directly in your inbox? Visit our subscription center and let us know what you're interested in learning more about.
View Subscription Center