In legal circles, disgorgement is known as an equitable remedy used to force a defendant to return money or property earned from illegal conduct. Traditionally, disgorgement has not been used as punishment, but a recent Second Circuit decision has suggested that disgorgement may now be a punitive remedy in disguise. In September 2005, Joseph Contorinis, an investment banker at Jefferies & Company, was given confidential information from a friend and fellow investment banker regarding a major financial acquisition. Contorinis used the non-public information to make very profitable trades for a Jeffries’ fund that Contorinis managed and controlled. By virtue of the information Contorinis had received and his subsequent trades, the fund earned a profit of $7,304,738, and avoided a loss of $5,345,700. Most importantly, Contorinis did not personally profit from the trade, with exception to $427,875 he received as compensation linked to the trades on behalf of his employer, Jeffries & Company. In February 2009, Contorinis was convicted of conspiracy to commit securities fraud and seven counts of securities fraud in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York. He was ordered to pay $12,650,438, which equaled the profit realized by the fund plus the avoided losses. Contorinis appealed his conviction and the forfeiture penalty. The Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit upheld his conviction, but overturned the forfeiture order on the grounds that the language of the criminal forfeiture statute did not support the proposition that a criminal defendant must forfeit profits received by an “innocent third party” that were “never possessed by the defendant.”[1] In the corresponding SEC civil proceeding, Contorinis was not so lucky. In SEC v. Contorinis,[2] the SEC sought to disgorge $7,260,604 from Contorinis. The District Court ultimately ordered Contorinis to disgorge the fund’s profits, plus another $2,485,205 in prejudgment interest—a total of nearly $10 million. Keep in mind, Contorinis only personally earned $427,875 from the illegal trades. Not surprisingly, Contorinis appealed, arguing that since he did not trade for his own account with his own funds, but instead on behalf of the fund whose assets belonged to third-party investors, he should not be responsible for paying back all of the fund’s profits earned from his illegal trades. In a 2-1 vote, the Second Circuit disagreed, relying on its long-standing “tipper-tippee” principle that attributes the gains of the recipient of non-public information (i.e. the “tippee”) to the informant (the “tipper”). In other words, the informant is required to disgorge all profits realized by the recipient of the non-public information, regardless of whether or not the informant himself realized any benefit. The Court opined, “…it must follow that the insider who, rather than passing the tip along to another, directly trades for that other’s account must equally disgorge the benefit he obtains for his favored beneficiary…We thus conclude that the district courts possess discretion to allocate disgorgement liability for insider trading to those responsible for the illegal acts, including to those with investment power over third-party accounts used to make illegal investments as well as to tippers.” The Second Circuit’s decision dramatically expands the SEC’s power to levy fines and force defendants to the negotiating table. Hedge fund managers and institutional investors should be keenly aware of the extent of the potential personal civil liability they may be exposed to if and when their third-party beneficiaries profit handsomely. Of equal import is that the decision leads one to speculate whether disgorgement in insider trading cases may have a punitive slant. By definition, disgorgement is an equitable remedy which, in theory, should disgorge from the defendant the amount of his gain. As noted by Judge Denny Chin, the sole dissenter, “[d]isgorgement thus should have the effect of returning a defendant to his status quo prior to the wrongdoings…Instead of returning Contorinis to his status quo prior to his wrongdoings, the district court’s disgorgement order penalized him by requiring him to pay an amount equal to the $7.2 million in profits earned by the fund and an additional $2.5 million in prejudgment interest.” Judge Chin makes a compelling point. Contorinis is required to “disgorge” almost 23 times the amount he profited from his insider trading. Clearly, such a disproportional penalty couched as equitable relief can reasonably be viewed as punitive in nature and therefore inappropriate in the context of equity. In fact, it may raise substantive due process implications since the Supreme Court’s Haslip case in 1991 that ruled the Constitution imposes substantive limits on the size of punitive damages awards. In Haslip, the Court said that, when the ratio of punitive to compensatory damages exceeds 4:1, such a punitive damages award is constitutionally suspect.[3] And since the Court said later in the Campbell case that few awards where that ratio exceeds single digits will satisfy due process, Contorinis, or the next defendant in his shoes, might be able to assert that the Constitution prohibits such a punishment dressed up as “equitable” relief.[4]
Disgorgement in the Second Circuit: Equitable Relief or Punishment?
Brian R. Weir-Harden
PartnerRELATED ARTICLES
How the SEC Widens Net Over Ethereum
October 14, 2022 | The GEE Blog, SEC
Digital Asset Businesses Amp Up Their Compliance Measures to Avoid Insider Trading Actions
August 26, 2022 | The GEE Blog, Department of Justice, SEC
Is Crypto a Security? Insider Trading Case Leads to DOJ, SEC Scrutiny
July 27, 2022 | The GEE Blog, SEC, Insider Trading
Fifth Circuit Holds That SEC Administrative Law Courts Are Unconstitutional
May 23, 2022 | The GEE Blog, SEC
Will SEC Become the ‘Securities and Environment Commission?’
March 30, 2022 | Environmental, Enforcement, The GEE Blog, SEC
How the SEC Widens Net Over Ethereum
October 14, 2022 | The GEE Blog, SEC
Digital Asset Businesses Amp Up Their Compliance Measures to Avoid Insider Trading Actions
August 26, 2022 | The GEE Blog, Department of Justice, SEC
Is Crypto a Security? Insider Trading Case Leads to DOJ, SEC Scrutiny
July 27, 2022 | The GEE Blog, SEC, Insider Trading
Fifth Circuit Holds That SEC Administrative Law Courts Are Unconstitutional
May 23, 2022 | The GEE Blog, SEC
Will SEC Become the ‘Securities and Environment Commission?’
March 30, 2022 | Environmental, Enforcement, The GEE Blog, SEC
The Enforcement Climate is Changing for ESG Disclosures
January 26, 2022 | Environmental, The GEE Blog
SEC Proposes Amendments to the Requirements of Rule 10b5-1 Trading Plans
December 22, 2021 | The GEE Blog, SEC, Financial Regulation, Insider Trading
SEC Announces FY2021 Results With 7 Percent Increase in New Enforcement Actions
November 30, 2021 | The GEE Blog, SEC
How Will the SEC Drive ESG Progress? First, We Measure
August 2, 2021 | Environmental, Environmental News, SEC
ESG Investing Guidance from the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
July 29, 2021 | The GEE Blog, SEC
UK’s Serious Fraud Office Issues Guidance on Deferred Prosecution Agreements
June 16, 2021 | The GEE Blog
DOJ Targets COVID-19 Fraud With Coordinated, Multi-District Law Enforcement Action
June 2, 2021 | The GEE Blog, Department of Justice
Whistleblower Awards from the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
May 24, 2021 | The GEE Blog, SEC
SEC Emerges as Main Regulator of Cryptocurrency
May 14, 2021 | The GEE Blog, Financial Regulation, SEC
SEC Whistleblower Program Continues Record-breaking Performance Amid New Chair's Support
April 28, 2021 | The GEE Blog, SEC
Gary Gensler to Lead SEC
April 16, 2021 | The GEE Blog, SEC
Half a Loaf: Congress Extends the Statute of Limitations on Some SEC Remedies
January 14, 2021 | The GEE Blog, SEC
SEC Again Highlights Risks of Investing in Chinese Securities
December 3, 2020 | The GEE Blog, SEC, Financial Regulation
SEC Steps Up Enforcement for Unsuitable Sales of Complex ETPs
November 18, 2020 | The GEE Blog, Financial Regulation, SEC
President’s Working Group Attempts to Increase Transparency in Chinese Investments
September 2, 2020 | The GEE Blog, SEC
SEC Highlights COVID-Related Risks Facing Broker-Dealers and Investment Advisers
August 31, 2020 | The GEE Blog, SEC, Financial Regulation
SEC Adopts Rule Amendments Regarding Proxy Voting Advice
July 29, 2020 | The GEE Blog, SEC
SEC Hosts Roundtable to Discuss Risks Associated With U.S.-Listed Chinese Companies
July 14, 2020 | The GEE Blog, SEC, Financial Regulation
CFTC Brings First Fraud Case Attributed to Pandemic
July 9, 2020 | The GEE Blog, Financial Regulation
Supreme Court Misses Its Chance To Define Limits of SEC’s Enforcement Authority
June 30, 2020 | The GEE Blog, SEC
First-Time Supreme Court Advocate Appointed to Argue the SEC’s Case in Lucia
January 23, 2018 | SEC, The GEE Blog
SEC’s Appointments Clause Dilemma Gets Worse
January 16, 2018 | SEC, The GEE Blog
SEC Scrutiny Brings Sanity to Hot ICO Market
November 9, 2017 | SEC, The GEE Blog
Who’s Watching the Watchdog? SEC Deals With Its Own Data Breach
September 25, 2017 | SEC, The GEE Blog
Don't Let DOJ Defections Fool You: Corporate Conduct Still in the Crosshairs
September 6, 2017 | Department of Justice, The GEE Blog
Corporate Law Alert - SEC Issues Guidance on Initial Coin Offerings and Cryptocurrencies
August 2, 2017 | The GEE Blog, SEC
SEC Chairman Announces 8 Core Principles
July 31, 2017 | SEC, The GEE Blog
U.S. Supreme Court Delivers Blow Limiting SEC Disgorgement Power
June 12, 2017 | SEC, The GEE Blog
The SEC’s Appointments Clause Dilemma
January 24, 2017 | Case to Watch, SEC, The GEE Blog
SEC Changes Some of Its Procedural Rules After Constitutional Challenges
September 7, 2016 | SEC, The GEE Blog
D.C. Circuit Affirms Constitutionality of SEC’s In-House Tribunals
September 2, 2016 | SEC, The GEE Blog
Accounting Fraud Getting Increased Attention from the SEC and Class Action Counsel
April 29, 2016 | SEC, The GEE Blog
SEC Completes Municipal Underwriter “Enforcement Sweep”
February 8, 2016 | SEC, The GEE Blog
SEC Reduces Dodd-Frank Whistleblower Award for "Unreasonable Delay," Announces Policy of "More Heavily" Punishing Delay After Award Program's Implementation
November 16, 2015 | SEC, The GEE Blog
Regulation S-P Violation: Are You Prepared For A Cyber-Security Breach?
October 8, 2015 | SEC, The GEE Blog
Insider Trading and Administrative Courts – More on Two Hot Topics That Have Now Converged
September 28, 2015 | Insider Trading, SEC, The GEE Blog
WHY NEWMAN MIGHT NOT BE HEADED TO THE SUPREME COURT
August 11, 2015 | Insider Trading, The GEE Blog
NINTH CIRCUIT SLAPS BACK REMOTE TIPPEE’S NEWMAN DEFENSE
July 15, 2015 | Insider Trading, The GEE Blog
THE BENEFITS OF COOPERATION – HYPERDYNAMICS AVOIDS INDICTMENT
May 29, 2015 | FCPA, The GEE Blog
The SEC Explains Its Rationale in Forum Selection in Contested Cases
May 26, 2015 | SEC, The GEE Blog
The SEC Explains Its Rationale in Forum Selection in Contested Cases
May 22, 2015 | SEC, The GEE Blog
Self-Reporting: A Wise Strategy or Chasing Unicorns?
April 28, 2015 | SEC, The GEE Blog
SENTENCING COMMISSION AMENDS FRAUD GUIDELINES
April 16, 2015 | White Collar and Investigations, The GEE Blog
Recent Enforcement Trends in the Commodity Markets (Part 1)
April 13, 2015 | Financial Regulation, The GEE Blog
Uniform Fiduciary Standards on the Horizon for Brokers and RIAs
April 10, 2015 | SEC, The GEE Blog
“HELLO, NEWMAN” -- GOVERNMENT CONTINUES TO LITIGATE REVERSED INSIDER TRADING CONVICTIONS
March 9, 2015 | Insider Trading, The GEE Blog
M&A DUE DILIGENCE FAILURES: FCPA & GOODYEAR
February 27, 2015 | FCPA, SEC, The GEE Blog
PART I - CORRUPTION ENFORCEMENT IN BRAZIL: WHAT DOES IT LOOK LIKE?
February 23, 2015 | SEC, The GEE Blog
Chasing the Gatekeepers
January 22, 2015 | SEC, The GEE Blog
DODD-FRANK WHISTLEBLOWER ACTIVITY GETTING EVEN HOTTER
September 23, 2014 | SEC, The GEE Blog
DODD-FRANK WHISTLEBLOWER LITIGATION HEATING UP
September 10, 2014 | SEC, The GEE Blog
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act - Keeping the Wolf at Bay
September 5, 2014 | FCPA, The GEE Blog
Regulators And Prosecutors Discuss Securities and Commodities Enforcement Priorities
August 15, 2014 | SEC, The GEE Blog
JUDGE RAKOFF CONTINUES TO QUESTION ADEQUACY OF JUDICIAL OVERSIGHT OF SEC
August 7, 2014 | SEC, The GEE Blog
Reader Responds to Recent Law Judge Blog Post
July 21, 2014 | The GEE Blog, SEC
The Gabelli Effect: How the Supreme Court’s Decision is Impacting Enforcement Actions
July 16, 2014 | SEC, The GEE Blog
REDUCING THE COST OF FCPA MONITORING
June 11, 2014 | Bank Securities Fraud, The GEE Blog
BELATED VINDICATION FOR THE SEC’S (PRIOR) SETTLEMENT POLICY
June 6, 2014 | Bank Securities Fraud, The GEE Blog
“Gatekeepers” Beware: A New Tool of the SEC
June 4, 2014 | Bank Securities Fraud, Financial Regulation, The GEE Blog
District Court Bolsters the Five-Year Statute of Limitations Defense to SEC Civil Enforcement Actions
May 20, 2014 | Bank Securities Fraud, The GEE Blog
Alert: SEC creates team to examine private equity and hedge funds
April 9, 2014 | The GEE Blog
Heightened SEC/DOJ FCPA Standards Offer Risks and Opportunities to Companies and Their Lawyers
March 18, 2014 | Financial Regulation, The GEE Blog
Is the FTC The Latest Weapon of Aggressive Short Sellers?
March 17, 2014 | Government Investigations, The GEE Blog
Top 10 Takeaways from ABA White Collar Crime Conference 2014 (Part 2 of 2)
March 13, 2014 | Government Investigations, The GEE Blog
Top 10 Takeaways from ABA White Collar Crime Conference 2014 (Part 1 of 2)
March 12, 2014 | Government Investigations, The GEE Blog
SEC’s New Priorities Continue to Come into Focus: Admissions of Liability
March 11, 2014 | Bank Securities Fraud, The GEE Blog
The SEC and Its “Strange Bedfellows” Argue Against Investors Seeking Damages for Fraud – Are Rebuffed by the Supreme Court
March 3, 2014 | Bank Securities Fraud, The GEE Blog
The CFTC: Armed and Dangerous
February 13, 2014 | Financial Regulation, Government Investigations, The GEE Blog
SEC Continues to Struggle in Insider Trading Jury Trials
February 7, 2014 | Insider Trading, The GEE Blog
Securities Regulators’ Increasing Use of Real-Time Monitoring Systems - Is Skynet Next?
January 31, 2014 | Financial Regulation, Government Investigations, Insider Trading, The GEE Blog
Going South: What U.S. Companies Need to Know About the FCPA and Doing Business in Latin America
January 30, 2014 | Criminal Procedure, Government Investigations, The GEE Blog
Welcome to The GEE Blog
January 18, 2014 | The GEE Blog
Let the Light of Day Shine
January 18, 2014 | Financial Regulation, The GEE Blog
Barnes & Thornburg Legal Alert - Government Regulators Continue to Make Insider Trading a Trial Priority
January 16, 2014 | Financial Regulation, The GEE Blog
SEC Highlights 2013 Accomplishments and Outlines 2014 Enforcement Priorities
January 2, 2014 | Financial Regulation, The GEE Blog
RELATED PRACTICE AREAS
Subscribe
Do you want to receive more valuable insights directly in your inbox? Visit our subscription center and let us know what you're interested in learning more about.
View Subscription Center