In a ground-breaking decision, the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit has defined “instrumentality” under the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA). Until now no federal appellate court had weighed in on a definition of “instrumentality,” leaving individuals and entities only the government’s interpretation of the statute for guidance. Not surprisingly, the government’s interpretation of what constitutes an “instrumentality” of the state for purposes of a bribe to one of its officials or employees included state-owned or state-controlled entities.[1] The Eleventh Circuit’s decision in United States v. Esquenazi, No. 11-15331 (May 16, 2014), in large part adopted the government’s interpretation, defining an “instrumentality” as “an entity controlled by the government of a foreign country that performs a function the controlling government treats as its own.” Thus, according to the Eleventh Circuit, the definition of instrumentality has two elements: (a) control by the state, and (b) performance of a state function. To guide a determination of the element of control, the appellate court offered a series of non-exhaustive factors, including: (a) the foreign government’s formal designation of that entity; (b) whether the government has a majority interest in the entity; (c) the foreign government’s ability to hire and fire the entity’s principals; (d) the extent to which the entity’s profits, if any, go directly into the governmental fisc, and, by the same token, the extent to which the government funds the entity if it fails to break even; and (e) the length of time these indicia have existed. To guide a determination of whether the entity performs a function the foreign government treats as its own, the court said it would consider: (a) whether the entity has a monopoly over the function it exists to carry out; (b) whether the foreign government subsidizes the costs associated with the entity providing services; (c) whether the entity provides services to the public at large in the foreign country; and (d) whether the public and the government of that foreign country generally perceive the entity to be performing a governmental function. Like the government, the Eleventh Circuit emphasized that both elements are fact-intensive questions. The appellate court’s refusal to establish a bright-line rule with respect to state-controlled or state-operated entities is disappointing, but not surprising. The Esquenazi case involved Haiti Teleco, an entity that the court recognized would be considered an instrumentality by almost any definition. However, the definition does leave some room for interpretation in a case in which the ownership is not as clear or the function not closely tied to a traditional government function. In-house anti-corruption policies will not require significant revision in light of Esquenazi, assuming they were adopted or revised with reference to the DOJ/SEC guide. However, companies should revisit their policies in light of this case, to ensure that it is clear that state-owned or state-operated entities do fall within the ambit of the FCPA. [1] A Resource Guide to the U.S. Foreign Corrupt Practices Act at 20 (November 14, 2012), available at http://www.justice.gov/criminal/fraud/fcpa/guide.pdf.
Federal Appellate Court Adopts Broad Definition of “Instrumentality” as used in the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act
RELATED ARTICLES
Fifth Circuit Holds That SEC Administrative Law Courts Are Unconstitutional
May 23, 2022 | The GEE Blog, SEC
DOJ Issues Expedited FCPA Opinion, Shows Willingness to Communicate With Requestors
February 7, 2022 | The GEE Blog, FCPA, Department of Justice
DOJ’s First FCPA Opinion Release in Six Years Highlights Long-Standing Principles
August 21, 2020 | The GEE Blog, FCPA
U.S. Supreme Court Delivers Blow Limiting SEC Disgorgement Power
June 12, 2017 | SEC, The GEE Blog
Recently Announced: DOJ Will Extend the FCPA Pilot Program
March 28, 2017 | Department of Justice, The GEE Blog
Fifth Circuit Holds That SEC Administrative Law Courts Are Unconstitutional
May 23, 2022 | The GEE Blog, SEC
DOJ Issues Expedited FCPA Opinion, Shows Willingness to Communicate With Requestors
February 7, 2022 | The GEE Blog, FCPA, Department of Justice
DOJ’s First FCPA Opinion Release in Six Years Highlights Long-Standing Principles
August 21, 2020 | The GEE Blog, FCPA
U.S. Supreme Court Delivers Blow Limiting SEC Disgorgement Power
June 12, 2017 | SEC, The GEE Blog
Recently Announced: DOJ Will Extend the FCPA Pilot Program
March 28, 2017 | Department of Justice, The GEE Blog
Department of Justice Rolls Out FCPA Enforcement Pilot Program
April 8, 2016 | Department of Justice, FCPA, The GEE Blog
U.S. v. Sigelman: Another FCPA Enforcement Setback for the DOJ
June 25, 2015 | FCPA, The GEE Blog
Self-Reporting: A Wise Strategy or Chasing Unicorns?
April 28, 2015 | SEC, The GEE Blog
Top 10 Takeaways from ABA White Collar Crime Conference 2015 (Part 1)
March 17, 2015 | The GEE Blog
M&A DUE DILIGENCE FAILURES: FCPA & GOODYEAR
February 27, 2015 | FCPA, SEC, The GEE Blog
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act - Keeping the Wolf at Bay
September 5, 2014 | FCPA, The GEE Blog
REDUCING THE COST OF FCPA MONITORING
June 11, 2014 | Bank Securities Fraud, The GEE Blog
Canadian Corruption of Foreign Officials Act Update: Three Takeaways from the Cryptometics Case
June 6, 2014 | Government Investigations, Privacy, The GEE Blog
Here Comes Canada: Corruption Prosecutions Likely to Increase Under the Amended CFPOA
April 22, 2014 | FCPA, Government Investigations, The GEE Blog
My Partner Left Me for the Government! DOJ’s First Opinion Procedure Release of 2014 Approves Buyout of Minority Shareholder-Turned-Government Official
March 25, 2014 | FCPA, The GEE Blog
D.C. District Court Order Provides a Warning About Attorney-Client Privilege Protection for Internal Investigations
March 20, 2014 | Internal Investigations, The GEE Blog
Heightened SEC/DOJ FCPA Standards Offer Risks and Opportunities to Companies and Their Lawyers
March 18, 2014 | Financial Regulation, The GEE Blog
Top 10 Takeaways from ABA White Collar Crime Conference 2014 (Part 2 of 2)
March 13, 2014 | Government Investigations, The GEE Blog
Top 10 Takeaways from ABA White Collar Crime Conference 2014 (Part 1 of 2)
March 12, 2014 | Government Investigations, The GEE Blog
Going South: What U.S. Companies Need to Know About the FCPA and Doing Business in Latin America
January 30, 2014 | Criminal Procedure, Government Investigations, The GEE Blog
RELATED PRACTICE AREAS
Subscribe
Do you want to receive more valuable insights directly in your inbox? Visit our subscription center and let us know what you're interested in learning more about.
View Subscription Center