A Magistrate Judge within the United States District Court for the District of New Jersey recently affirmed the significance of social media postings in litigation proceedings, finding deactivation of a plaintiff’s Facebook account to constitute spoliation of evidence and warrant the issuance of an adverse inference against him at trial. Specifically, in Gatto v. United Air Lines, Inc., found here, a plaintiff alleged to have suffered an injury while working at the airport claimed, among other things, that his injuries precluded him from working and rendered him permanently disabled. In an effort to refute his claims, the defendants sought discovery relating to his social activities and alleged damages, including posts by plaintiff on his Facebook account.
Though he executed consent forms for various third parties, the plaintiff failed to authorize the release of records pertaining to his Facebook account, placing the parties before the Court to consider the issue. In doing so, the Court ordered the plaintiff to execute the authorization. Further, the plaintiff agreed to change his password to one provided to the defendants. Ultimately, defense counsel accessed the plaintiff’s Facebook account, prompting messages to be sent from Facebook to the plaintiff indicating an unknown IP address had logged into his account. Upon inquiry, defense counsel advised plaintiff’s counsel they had accessed the account. Defense counsel further sought to obtain a download of all information on plaintiff’s Facebook account, which Facebook would not directly provide in response to a subpoena, and received a proposal from plaintiff that he download a copy of the information and certify that the data had not been altered since the time he had been ordered to provide defendants with access to his account. Rather than receiving such download, defendants were advised a month later that the plaintiff had deactivated his entire Facebook account (purportedly due to concerns associated with the notices he had received regarding unknown IP addresses accessing his account) and all data had been lost. Accordingly, the Court faced the issue of whether plaintiff’s actions rose to the level of spoliation of evidence. Irrespective of the parties’ disputes as to whether defense counsel improperly had authorized the account or whether plaintiff had deactivated or permanently deleted the account, the Court found an adverse inference instruction to be appropriately recourse for the loss of evidence. In reaching this conclusion, the Court found plaintiff to have controlled the evidence at issue, and that the evidence was both relevant and a reasonably foreseeable area for discovery. The Court further determined that the level of prejudice suffered by defendants in losing any access to the evidence warranted an adverse inference instruction to attempt to level the playing field. The Court, however, declined to award attorney’s fees as a further sanction. This case provides useful insights in all litigation matters for which social media could be sought. Not only does the case affirm the relevance and discoverable nature of social media posts such as those appearing on Facebook, but it provides a cautionary tale as to the potential consequences to parties who allow for the destruction of such evidence. Employers should be aware that this warning applies not only to plaintiffs, but also could be implicated in instances in which relevant information and posts are deleted from an employer’s social media site or by decision makers on their personal accounts.RELATED ARTICLES
Shut Your Mouth: Policy Prohibiting Bad-Mouthing the Company Ruled Unlawful
August 27, 2020 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
Asking: “How much do you currently make?” in 2018?
December 29, 2017 | EEOC, Employment Lessons, Currents - Employment Law
Can Employers Terminate an Employee Because of Vacation Photos Posted to Facebook?
April 28, 2017 | Employee Leave, Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Using an Employee’s Social Media Posts to Prove Laziness? Think Again
November 21, 2016 | Employment Lessons, Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Employers Need Not Tolerate Workers Screaming On the Electronic Street Corner
June 6, 2016 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Shut Your Mouth: Policy Prohibiting Bad-Mouthing the Company Ruled Unlawful
August 27, 2020 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
Asking: “How much do you currently make?” in 2018?
December 29, 2017 | EEOC, Employment Lessons, Currents - Employment Law
Can Employers Terminate an Employee Because of Vacation Photos Posted to Facebook?
April 28, 2017 | Employee Leave, Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Using an Employee’s Social Media Posts to Prove Laziness? Think Again
November 21, 2016 | Employment Lessons, Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Employers Need Not Tolerate Workers Screaming On the Electronic Street Corner
June 6, 2016 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
The Viral Spiral: How An Employee’s Facebook Post Dragged Her Employer Into A Social Media Controversy
November 24, 2015 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
EMOJI-GOSH! How Emojis in Workplace Communications Can Spark A Lawsuit (Or Make It Harder To Defend One)
November 20, 2015 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Employee Suspended For Tweet: What We Can Learn From This Real World Example
November 20, 2015 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Employers: Twitter is Going Crazy Over The #InternationalMensDay Hashtag
November 19, 2015 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Trending Now: How the Latest News Going Viral Can Lead to Employment Litigation
November 17, 2015 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
DO IT FOR THE VINE! How This Week’s Viral Social Media Trend Can Spark Legal Liability in the Workplace
November 11, 2015 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Employee Fired for Facebook Selfie
October 19, 2015 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Employers Won’t “Like” Ruling Allowing Class Action Notifications via Social Media
May 6, 2015 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Breaking News: Employees Are Still Posting Inappropriate Content On Facebook. So Let’s Just Learn From Their Lack of Judgment
May 1, 2015 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
The Tweet Heard Round the World
February 10, 2015 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
This Message Will Self Destruct in 10 Seconds: Snapchat, Confide and the Implications of Disappearing Content on Your Business
February 9, 2015 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
The Year in Social Media: Four Big Developments from 2014
December 29, 2014 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Avoid Going From Ho! Ho! Ho! To Oh No! No! No!
December 23, 2014 | Employment Discrimination, Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
NLRB “Likes” Employees’ Facebook Argument
September 2, 2014 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
EEOC turns its focus to the impact of social media in employment litigation
March 20, 2014 | EEOC, Employment Discrimination, Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Illinois Case Reminds (Again): Document Rights and Responsibilities On Company Social Media Accounts
March 10, 2014 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
How much can a Facebook post cost you? About $80K
February 27, 2014 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Wisconsin Likely to Limit Access to Social Media Accounts
February 21, 2014 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Academic Studies About Screening Applicants’ Social Media: New Cottage Industry?
January 15, 2014 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Facebook Background Checking: Shouldn’t Smart Applicants Check Their Privacy Settings?
January 8, 2014 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
“Using Social Media to Discriminate”: Please Read the Fine Print
December 2, 2013 | Employment Discrimination, Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Facebook Users Beware: Even Posts You Claim Not to Have Written Can Haunt You
October 29, 2013 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Your Facebook “Like” May Be Constitutionally-Protected Speech
September 27, 2013 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Social Media Policy Provides Legitimate, Nondiscriminatory Reason for Termination
September 25, 2013 | Employment Discrimination, Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Employers May Inadvertently Break the Law When They Discipline Employees for Facebook “Wall” Posts
August 30, 2013 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
NLRB Offers Further Clarification Regarding Expression of Employees’ Section 7 Rights on Social Media
May 23, 2013 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Gov. Christie The First to Stand Up to Social Media Legislation Wave?
May 13, 2013 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Three States Pass Legislation on Limiting Access to Social Medial Passwords
May 3, 2013 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Congress Rejects Password Protection Amendment To CISPA
April 24, 2013 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Washington State Legislators Withdraw Bill Allowing Employers to Access Social Media Accounts During Investigations
April 11, 2013 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Texas Legislature Will Consider Employers’ Ability to Access Social Media Passwords
January 7, 2013 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
When Is Facebook Activity "Solicitation?"
November 26, 2012 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Hand it Over: Federal Judge Orders Plaintiffs in Discrimination Lawsuit to Produce Cell Phones and Facebook Account Passwords
November 21, 2012 | Employment Discrimination, Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
California Passes Law to Regulate Access to Employees’ Social Media Accounts
October 4, 2012 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
The NLRB, EEOC and Social Media
September 4, 2012 | Pregnancy, Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Entertainers, Facebook Messages and the Work-Product Doctrine?
May 22, 2012 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
RELATED PRACTICE AREAS
Subscribe
Do you want to receive more valuable insights directly in your inbox? Visit our subscription center and let us know what you're interested in learning more about.
View Subscription Center