A federal district court in Illinois recently granted an employer’s motion to dismiss federal and state wage and hour claims asserted by two employees because the court determined it lacked subject matter jurisdiction. In Avila v Watts Electric Co, Inc, the employer made offers of judgment to both employees, which included the “total amount of wages owed” and “reasonable attorney’s fees and costs to be determined by the court.” The plaintiffs each rejected these offers of judgment. Watts Electric Co. then filed a Rule 68 motion to dismiss for lack of subject matter jurisdiction, arguing that the failure to accept the offers of judgment deprived the court of jurisdiction and rendered the case moot.
The court agreed and dismissed the matter. As the court explained, both plaintiffs must have a personal interest in the case “at the beginning of the litigation, and their interests must persist throughout its entirety.” Once a litigant loses his personal interest at any time, the case becomes moot and the court no longer has subject matter jurisdiction since there is no longer a controversy over which the court can assert judicial power. Subject matter jurisdiction challenges can either be facial or factual. A facial challenge attacks the sufficiency of the plaintiff’s complaint and, in response, the plaintiff must “only show the existence of facts that could . . . establish standing.” In comparison, a factual challenge accepts the sufficiency of the plaintiff’s complaint, but attacks the personal interest in which the plaintiff has in such case and, in response, the plaintiff bears the burden of coming forward with competent proof that standing exists. In Avila, the employer presented a factual challenge under Rule 68, arguing that the case became moot once it made a full and complete offer of judgment to satisfy the plaintiffs’ entire demands. In support of this argument, Watts Electric presented sworn affidavits with the two offers of judgment as well as the payroll records for the time periods in which the plaintiffs alleged wage and hour violations, demonstrating that offers were complete. The court found that the plaintiffs provided no support for their arguments that the offers were incomplete or questionable. Because the plaintiffs failed to meet their burden and no motion for class certification under the FLSA was filed, the federal court granted the employer’s motion and dismissed the case. The Avila decision is good example in which a thoughtful defense litigation strategy can minimize the costs and potential damages an employer could incur in a wage and hour matter.Offers of Judgment Support Dismissal of Wage and Hour Claims
RELATED ARTICLES
Illinois Federal Court Rejects Arbitration of BIPA Class Action
June 10, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law
Illinois Supreme Court Affirms School District Must Pay for Emergency Construction
June 5, 2020 | Construction Law
Seventh Circuit Confirms Article III Standing for BIPA Plaintiffs
May 7, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law
Plaintiffs Prevail in Appeal of Illinois Prevailing Wage Act Case
April 27, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law, Construction Law, Contracts
Illinois Makes Workers Compensation More Accessible for COVID-19 First Responders and Front Line Workers
April 14, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law, Employee Health Issues
Illinois Federal Court Rejects Arbitration of BIPA Class Action
June 10, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law
Illinois Supreme Court Affirms School District Must Pay for Emergency Construction
June 5, 2020 | Construction Law
Seventh Circuit Confirms Article III Standing for BIPA Plaintiffs
May 7, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law
Plaintiffs Prevail in Appeal of Illinois Prevailing Wage Act Case
April 27, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law, Construction Law, Contracts
Illinois Makes Workers Compensation More Accessible for COVID-19 First Responders and Front Line Workers
April 14, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law, Employee Health Issues
Third-Party Biometric Timekeeping Provider Chops Down BIPA Liability
April 14, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law
Illinois Court Shines a (Heat) Lamp on Insurer’s Duty to Defend BIPA Claims
March 26, 2020 | Policyholder Protection, Privacy, Currents - Employment Law
Illinois Issues COVID-19 Stay-at-Home Order, Excluding Essential Businesses and Operations
March 20, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law
Chicago Workers to Earn $15 Minimum Wage by 2021
December 16, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law
Big Changes For Illinois Employers: Workplace Transparency Act
September 24, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Workplace Culture and Conduct
Illinois Imposes Retainage Limits in Construction Contracts
August 28, 2019 | Construction Law, Contracts
Illinois EPA Amendment Lowers Standard For Discrimination Claims
August 8, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Employment Discrimination
Illinois Amends Equal Pay Act To Ban Questions About Applicants' Pay History
August 6, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Employment Lessons
New Illinois #MeToo Legislation Targets Sexual Harassment in the Workplace
April 3, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Workplace Culture and Conduct, Employment Discrimination
New Expense Reimbursement Requirements in Illinois Leave Employers Guessing
January 22, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law
Don’t Forget: New Procedures for Illinois Charges of Discrimination
October 19, 2018 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
Paid sick leave in Chicago and Cook County: Are you compliant with notice and carry over requirements?
June 29, 2018 | Employee Leave, Currents - Employment Law
Which Side Will Justice Gorsuch Fall On Public Sector Union Fees?
March 5, 2018 | Supreme Court Watch, Currents - Employment Law
ICE Raids on 7-Eleven Franchise Stores Result in 21 Arrests
January 12, 2018 | Employment Lessons, High Stakes Employment Issues, Currents - Employment Law
Attention Illinois Employers: 3 Handbook Policies to Revisit Now
October 13, 2017 | EEOC, Employee Leave, Employment Lessons, Currents - Employment Law
Illinois Governor Vetoes Employment Bills Aimed at Salary History Inquiries, Wage Issues
August 29, 2017 | Employment Lessons, Currents - Employment Law
Illinois Amends Unemployment Act
December 9, 2015 | Employment Lessons, Currents - Employment Law
New rules provide insights for pregnancy accommodations in Illinois
September 18, 2015 | Pregnancy, Currents - Employment Law
Pregnancy Non-Discrimination Poster Now Required in Illinois
January 14, 2015 | Employee Health Issues, Employment Discrimination, Pregnancy, Currents - Employment Law
New Illinois Law Will Require Pregnancy Accommodations Starting January 1, 2015
September 5, 2014 | Employee Health Issues, Pregnancy, Currents - Employment Law
Illinois Governor Signs Payroll Card Law
August 7, 2014 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Pregnancy accommodations could soon be required in Illinois
June 3, 2014 | Employee Health Issues, Pregnancy, Currents - Employment Law
Illinois Case Reminds (Again): Document Rights and Responsibilities On Company Social Media Accounts
March 10, 2014 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Illinois Courts to Require Redaction of Personal Identity Information
October 31, 2012 | Traditional Labor, Currents - Employment Law
High Court Will Not Evaluate Whether Summary Judgment Orders Violate Plaintiffs’ Seventh Amendment Rights
October 16, 2012 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
New Illinois Law Prohibits Employers from Seeking Social Media Password Information
August 6, 2012 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Don’t Screen Out State Laws When Hiring
June 29, 2012 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
Employee Social Networking Password Protection May Soon Become Law in Illinois
June 26, 2012 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Court Rules Participation in Post-Lawsuit Internal Investigation is Protected Activity
June 22, 2012 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
RELATED PRACTICE AREAS
Subscribe
Do you want to receive more valuable insights directly in your inbox? Visit our subscription center and let us know what you're interested in learning more about.
View Subscription Center