A cancer survivor’s Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) lawsuit against a prospective employer was rejected this week by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit in Kilcrease v. Domenico Transportation Co. The case involved a truck driver who, after successfully overcoming cancer, applied for work with a trucking company, Domenico Transportation. The job required applicants to (1) hold a Class A commercial driver’s license, (2) have three years of recent and verifiable mountain driving (the company is located in Colorado), (3) have no moving violations within a three-year period and (4) be able to drive year-round in the Colorado mountains. During the application process, the employee disclosed that he had been unemployed for several years due to cancer, but that it now was in remission. The trucking company subsequently rejected his application, ostensibly because he lacked three years of recent driving experience, which was required by the company’s auto-insurance underwriter. The driver warned Domenico that not hiring him violated the ADA, but the company did not change its mind. The truck driver then sued under the ADA. The district court rejected his claims, and this week, the 10th Circuit agreed – relying in large part on the employer’s written job description. The court found that the applicant was not a qualified individual with a disability because he was unable to perform the essential functions of the job. This is why a written job description can be critical. The job description in this particular case required qualified applicants to have three years of mountain driving experience, but as it turns out, the plaintiff only had about half that. In evaluating the criteria for the job, the court gave considerable weight to the employer’s depiction of the job’s essential functions – and particularly the three-year mountain driving requirement - and refused to second-guess the employer’s rationale because the requirements were job-related, uniformly enforced and consistent with business necessity. As a result, the court concluded that the plaintiff could not establish a prima facie case of discrimination under the ADA because he failed to establish that he was a qualified individual with a disability. The job description in this case was central to the company’s decision not to hire the plaintiff and ultimately, was the crux of the judicial decision to dismiss the case against the company. If the trucking company had not maintained a job description with specific requirements – such as three years of mountain driving – the company would have been forced to prove the requirements through oral testimony. Inherently, proof through oral testimony is much harder to establish and is a lot easier to challenge. As seen in this case, having a written job description that accurately reflects the requirements of the job, and which is adhered to by the company, can sidestep a lot of these problems. The full case citation is Kilcrease v. Domenico Transportation Co., 10th Circuit Case No. 15-1320 (July 12, 2016).
10th Circuit ADA Ruling Drives Home the Importance of Written Job Descriptions
Hannesson Murphy
PartnerRELATED ARTICLES
EEOC Issues Guidance on Opioid Use by Employees
August 7, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law, EEOC, Employee Health Issues
Sixth Circuit Confirms Standard for 'Regarded As' Discrimination Under the ADA
November 12, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Employment Discrimination
Position Is Not Vacant If It Is Being Held For an Employee on FMLA Leave
October 14, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Employee Health Issues
Seventh Circuit Holds ADA Does Not Necessarily Require Remote Work Arrangement
July 8, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Employee Health Issues
Extreme Obesity Not Necessarily a Disability Under ADA, Says Seventh Circuit
June 20, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Employee Health Issues
EEOC Issues Guidance on Opioid Use by Employees
August 7, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law, EEOC, Employee Health Issues
Sixth Circuit Confirms Standard for 'Regarded As' Discrimination Under the ADA
November 12, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Employment Discrimination
Position Is Not Vacant If It Is Being Held For an Employee on FMLA Leave
October 14, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Employee Health Issues
Seventh Circuit Holds ADA Does Not Necessarily Require Remote Work Arrangement
July 8, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Employee Health Issues
Extreme Obesity Not Necessarily a Disability Under ADA, Says Seventh Circuit
June 20, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Employee Health Issues
Sixth Circuit Explains Not All Work Restrictions Are Disabilities Under The ADA
June 11, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Employment Lessons
Sixth Circuit Holds Full-Time Presence at Work not Essential Simply Because an Employer Says So
July 20, 2018 | Employment Discrimination, Pregnancy, Currents - Employment Law
Zero-Tolerance for Upside-Down Burritos
April 19, 2018 | Employee Health Issues, Employment Lessons, Currents - Employment Law
Accommodate Much? Restrictive Seventh Circuit Leave Ruling Lives On
April 5, 2018 | EEOC, Letter of the Law, Currents - Employment Law
Letter of the Law – A Revival!
April 5, 2018 | Letter of the Law, Currents - Employment Law
Don’t Get Caught in the Weeds: Hiring Issues and Medical Marijuana
August 21, 2017 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
Lessons Learned – Engaging in Protected Activity Does Not Shield An Employee From Termination
June 9, 2017 | Employment Lessons, Currents - Employment Law
College Not Required to Alter Academic Program for Reasonable Accommodation
May 22, 2017 | Employment Lessons, Currents - Employment Law
Employer’s 'Stirring Up' Testimony Allows Plaintiff to Pursue Section 504 and ADA Claims
April 3, 2017 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
Easy Come, Easy Go: Appeals Court Reverses $2.6 Million Award in ADA Case
March 24, 2017 | Employment Lessons, Currents - Employment Law
A U.S. Supreme Court ADA Showdown Is A-Brewin’: Eleventh Circuit Contradicts Seventh Circuit Regarding Non-Competitive Mandatory Reassignments
December 14, 2016 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
EEOC: Drug Testing Policies Must Allow for Reasonable Accommodation
August 31, 2016 | EEOC, Currents - Employment Law
Court Provides Roadmap for Managing 'Intolerable' Behavior From Employee with Disabilities
July 8, 2016 | Employee Health Issues, Currents - Employment Law
New Trend Alert – Websites Must be Accessible to the Blind to Comply with the ADA
June 22, 2016 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Flex-Time and Telecommuting Requests: Potential Traps for the Unwary Employer
June 14, 2016 | Employee Health Issues, Currents - Employment Law
What Employers must know about the Americans with Disabilities Act
June 8, 2016 | EEOC, Currents - Employment Law
Telecommuting as an ADA Accommodation
June 7, 2016 | Employee Health Issues, Currents - Employment Law
EEOC Consent Decrees Highlight That Employers Must Prevent ADA Claims -- Or Pay the Consequences
April 15, 2016 | EEOC, Currents - Employment Law
Morbid Obesity Not Necessarily a Disability Under Americans with Disabilities Act
April 7, 2016 | Employee Health Issues, Currents - Employment Law
Seventh Circuit to Review Wellness Program Under Americans with Disabilities Act
February 29, 2016 | EEOC, Currents - Employment Law
HR Note to Self: Accommodate Obvious Disabilities
January 15, 2016 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
Permanent Lifting Restrictions and the ADA
January 8, 2016 | EEOC, Currents - Employment Law
EEOC Issues Additional Guidance on Job Rights for Employees with HIV
December 3, 2015 | Employee Health Issues, Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
EMOJI-GOSH! How Emojis in Workplace Communications Can Spark A Lawsuit (Or Make It Harder To Defend One)
November 20, 2015 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Employee Who Threatened to Shoot His Colleagues with a Shotgun Not a “Qualified Individual” For the Purposes of Oregon’s Disability Statute, Says Ninth Circuit
October 12, 2015 | Employee Health Issues, Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
Hiring Advertisements May Help Avoid Claims Under the ADA
September 1, 2015 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
Employer Changes Mind, Denies Accommodation to Deaf Applicant, Heads to Jury
September 1, 2015 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
Clarity from the 9th Circuit: The ADA Does Not Require Employer to Keep a Potentially Violent Employee
August 14, 2015 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
Employee Can’t Count to 15 Under ADA Using Volunteers or Other Companies’ Employees
July 27, 2015 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
ADA Decision Shows Need to Work with Employee Who Doesn’t Fit the … Mold
July 15, 2015 | Employee Health Issues, Currents - Employment Law
Does Being “Perceived As” Muslim Support A Title VII Claim? One Court Says Yes
June 22, 2015 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
Recent Case Illustrates How Types of Associational Discrimination Claims Can Play Out in Litigation
June 12, 2015 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
Getting What You Don’t Ask For – The Perils Of ADA Accommodation By Inference
May 27, 2015 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
Paradigm Shift: Triple Standard of Reasonable Accommodations
April 30, 2015 | Employment Discrimination, Pregnancy, Currents - Employment Law
EEOC RELEASES PROPOSED RULE ON EMPLOYER WELLNESS PROGRAMS
April 17, 2015 | EEOC, Currents - Employment Law
3 Types of Associational Discrimination Claims
March 23, 2015 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
EEOC’s Targeted Attack of Inflexible Leave Policies Under the ADA
March 3, 2015 | EEOC, Employee Health Issues, Currents - Employment Law
Be Careful What They Wish For
January 20, 2015 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
ADA: Does “Regarded As” Still Matter?
December 1, 2014 | Employment Discrimination, Letter of the Law, Currents - Employment Law
The EEOC Sues Yet Another Employer for Allegedly Violating the ADA With Its Inflexible Leave Policy
November 18, 2014 | EEOC, Currents - Employment Law
3 Key P's for Minimizing Liability for Employee Health Issues
November 17, 2014 | Employment Discrimination, Letter of the Law, Currents - Employment Law
Ebola – How Should Employers Respond?
November 4, 2014 | Employee Health Issues, Currents - Employment Law
Nassar A Year Later: Pennsylvania ADA Retaliation Case Considers Impact of Supreme Court’s Decision
November 3, 2014 | Letter of the Law, Currents - Employment Law
There’s No Question – The EEOC’s Strategic Enforcement Plan Is In Full Bloom
October 2, 2014 | EEOC, Currents - Employment Law
The Interactive Process Under the ADA – Are you engaging in it?
August 25, 2014 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
FMLA AND FITNESS FOR DUTY
August 8, 2014 | Letter of the Law, Currents - Employment Law
New EEOC Guidance – Pregnant Employees May Now Be Entitled To Accommodations
July 15, 2014 | EEOC, Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
ENOUGH IS ENOUGH: COURT OKS “INFLEXIBLE” SIX MONTHS OF LEAVE
June 16, 2014 | Employee Health Issues, Currents - Employment Law
ADA Requires Reasonable Accommodation, Not Employee’s Preferred Accommodation
June 9, 2014 | EEOC, Currents - Employment Law
Flextime consideration is now law in some places
May 2, 2014 | Employee Health Issues, Currents - Employment Law
Severe Obesity May Be An ADA-covered Disability, Court Rules
April 30, 2014 | Employee Health Issues, Currents - Employment Law
No Exposure to Allergens in the Workplace – Is there a Reasonable Accommodation Under the ADA?
March 6, 2014 | Employee Health Issues, Currents - Employment Law
Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals Analyzes the History of the ADAAA and Remands Case Involving “Temporary Disability” to District Court
January 24, 2014 | Employee Health Issues, Currents - Employment Law
Play It Safe II: Employers At Risk If They Don’t Methodically Process ADA Issues
January 21, 2014 | Employee Health Issues, Currents - Employment Law
Play it Safe: Always Remember to Consider Potential Disability-Related Accommodations For Workplace Restrictions
January 16, 2014 | Employee Health Issues, Currents - Employment Law
Don’t Talk About Employee’s Disability – Even In A Sports Analogy
December 9, 2013 | Employee Health Issues, Currents - Employment Law
Don't Forget About Potential Associational Claims
December 6, 2013 | EEOC, Currents - Employment Law
Behind the Numbers: Employment Discrimination Cases at the Federal Level Decline, But Why?
November 26, 2013 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
Timely Attendance Isn’t An Essential Job Function?!?
October 18, 2013 | Employee Health Issues, Currents - Employment Law
Court Finds Employer’s ADA Direct Threat Evidence Insufficient
September 6, 2013 | Employee Health Issues, Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
Employers May Come Up, Um, Short Under ADA
June 19, 2013 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
ADA Charge Verified by Counsel Is Insufficient; Plaintiff Failed to Exhaust Administrative Remedies
April 4, 2013 | EEOC, Currents - Employment Law
Court Upholds Random Alcohol Testing of New Coke Plant Employees
February 27, 2013 | EEOC, Currents - Employment Law
Accommodating the Commute
February 12, 2013 | Employee Health Issues, Currents - Employment Law
Mixed Motive Allegation Not Enough To Sustain “Regarded as” ADAAA Case
January 16, 2013 | Employee Health Issues, Currents - Employment Law
No ADA Protection for Termination Due to Fear of Swine Flu
December 21, 2012 | Employee Health Issues, Currents - Employment Law
EEOC Must Abide By 300-Day Rule in Pattern and Practice Case, Says New Jersey Federal Court
October 22, 2012 | EEOC, Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
Seventh Circuit Reverses Course on Reassignment Accommodation
September 10, 2012 | Employee Health Issues, Currents - Employment Law
Is Employer-Ordered Counseling a Medical Exam Covered By The ADA?
August 29, 2012 | Employee Health Issues, Currents - Employment Law
RELATED PRACTICE AREAS
Subscribe
Do you want to receive more valuable insights directly in your inbox? Visit our subscription center and let us know what you're interested in learning more about.
View Subscription Center