Co-authored by John Corbett and Andy Detherage. The recent rainstorms in California rightly have been hailed as the end of a lengthy drought. The inches of rain which fell in the span of a week have filled reservoirs and raised the water table in the parched ground. Such a large volume of water, however, increases the danger of landslides in California’s notoriously unconsolidated hillsides and bluffs, and with it, the possibility of disputes over whether particular ground movement claims are covered by their liability policies. Let’s look at a hypothetical example. XYZ Construction is laying pipes under an existing street at the top of a bluff. In the course of digging trenches to hold the pipes, one of XYZ’s diggers accidentally breaks the water main line. Water spurts out of the main line, quickly fills the trench, and spills across the ground toward the top of the bluff. Several hours later, the saturated bluff, already weakened by rain, collapses onto a building below, causing severe damage to the structure. The owner of the damaged structure files a lawsuit against XYZ. XYZ, like virtually all construction contractors, has purchased commercial general liability (CGL) insurance. CGL policies insure the policyholder’s liability for bodily injury or property damage, and provide it with a defense against claims asserting such liability. XYZ’s insurer refuses to defend it against the third-party claim, noting that the policy has an earth movement exclusion. Under that exclusion, there is no coverage for liability arising out of “the subsidence of land or earth movement, including landslide, earthquake, mudflow, earth sinking, earth rising or earth shifting.” The insurance company notes that, because the claim against XYZ clearly arises out of earth movement, there is no possibility of coverage. Is the insurance company correct? Many CGL policies have earth movement exclusions. The placement of such exclusions in CGL policies is a frequent source of friction between insurance companies and policyholders, because if applicable they can defeat coverage of a substantial source of bet-the-company-size liability. Not surprisingly, the scope of earth movement exclusions has been heavily litigated. Earth movement exclusions can vary widely between insurance companies. As it turns out, these differences can make or break the insurance company’s coverage defense. Where an earth movement exclusion contains express language making it applicable without regard to cause, courts have applied them broadly to defeat coverage. However, where the exclusion does not have such language, courts have been less willing to apply them to earth movement attributable to human causes, as CGL policies by their nature insure against accidents. This is especially the case where the exclusion lists examples of earth movement that are best characterized as natural, such as landslides, mudflows, earthquakes, and so on. In such circumstances, many – though not all – courts read the exclusion to be ambiguous, and under the rules of insurance policy construction, resolve interpretation of the exclusion in favor of coverage.
RELATED ARTICLES
Watershed California Decision Finds for Policyholder in COVID-19 Business Interruption Appeal
July 14, 2022 | Policyholder Protection, Property Insurance
Should You Rely on Your Insurance Agent to Tell Insurance Company About a New Claim?
June 7, 2022 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance
When You Get Sued, Don’t Forget to Tell Your Insurance Company
June 1, 2022 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance
Can Insurance Cover False Claims Act Claims?
May 27, 2022 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance
D&O Policy ‘Related Claims’ Ruling Highlights Importance of How Your Policy is Written
March 23, 2022 | Policyholder Protection, do
Watershed California Decision Finds for Policyholder in COVID-19 Business Interruption Appeal
July 14, 2022 | Policyholder Protection, Property Insurance
Should You Rely on Your Insurance Agent to Tell Insurance Company About a New Claim?
June 7, 2022 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance
When You Get Sued, Don’t Forget to Tell Your Insurance Company
June 1, 2022 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance
Can Insurance Cover False Claims Act Claims?
May 27, 2022 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance
D&O Policy ‘Related Claims’ Ruling Highlights Importance of How Your Policy is Written
March 23, 2022 | Policyholder Protection, do
Resolving Insurance Coverage Disputes – What Every Legal Department Should Know
March 11, 2022 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance
Mind the Gap: Coverage Gaps Created by Commercial General Liability Policies
October 15, 2021 | Policyholder Protection, Commercial General Liability
Out of Sight, But Not Out of Mind: Facts Outside the Pleadings and the Duty to Defend
October 15, 2021 | Policyholder Protection, Duty To Defend
What’s Wrong With This Picture? Five Questions to Ask for Improving Contractual Indemnification Provisions
October 15, 2021 | Policyholder Protection, Policy
Insurance Coverage for Emerging Contaminants
October 15, 2021 | Policyholder Protection, Environmental, Insurance
Interview With Greg Shantz, General Counsel of CertaPro Painters Ltd.
October 15, 2021 | Policyholder Protection
The Growing Science Behind Direct Physical Loss or Damage from COVID-19
August 2, 2021 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance, Property Insurance
This, That, and the Other: Different Insurance Policies Can Cover the Same Loss
June 21, 2021 | Policyholder Protection, Additional Insured, Insurance
State of the Law for Business Interruption Insurance Coverage for COVID-19 Claims
May 14, 2021 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance, Claims
Important Timing Considerations for COVID-19 Business Interruption Claims
April 27, 2021 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance, Policy
Another Favorable Ruling for California Policyholders Seeking Coverage for COVID-19 Losses
April 1, 2021 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance, Policy, Claims
Parent Company Providing Workers Compensation Can’t Be Sued By Subsidiary’s Employee
March 3, 2021 | Construction Law, Policyholder Protection, Insurance Coverage, Contracts
Tribal Property Insurance Found to Cover COVID-19 Business Interruption Losses
January 25, 2021 | Policyholder Protection, Policy, Property Insurance
The Growing Captive Insurance Market: Is It Right for Your Business Needs?
December 9, 2020 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance, Policy
Top 7 Opportunities and Obstacles in Negotiating Pollution Coverage
December 9, 2020 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance
Gone Phishin': How Does Insurance Apply To Business Email Compromise Losses?
December 9, 2020 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance, Cyber Insurance, Data Breach
The Right to Independent Counsel: What It Is and When You Should Demand It
December 7, 2020 | Policyholder Protection
COVID-19 and Business Interruption Insurance
December 7, 2020 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance, Policy
D&O Renewals in the Age of COVID-19
December 7, 2020 | Policyholder Protection, do, Insurance, Policy
Assessing the Value of Representations and Warranty insurance
December 4, 2020 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance
Michigan Supreme Court Holds a Contractor’s Defective Work Is an ‘Occurrence’
July 8, 2020 | Construction Law, Construction Defects, Insurance Coverage, Commercial General Liability
Insurance Coverage for Emerging Contaminants
June 3, 2020 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance, Environmental
Will Legislation Require Coverage for COVID-19 Business Interruption Losses?
April 3, 2020 | Policyholder Protection, Policy, Insurance, Claims
Inadvertent Construction Defects Are an ‘Occurrence’ Under the CGL Insurance Policy
February 25, 2020 | Construction Law, Construction Defects, Insurance Coverage, Policyholder Protection, Commercial General Liability
Case Summaries
December 10, 2019 | Policyholder Protection, Policy, Claims
An Appraisal Of The Appraisal Remedy In Property Insurance
November 26, 2019 | Policyholder Protection, Property Insurance
Coverage May Exist For Companies Facing Allegations Related To Sexual Abuse
November 19, 2019 | Policyholder Protection, Occurrence, Policy
Building An Insurance Bad Faith Case
November 14, 2019 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance
Does Your CGL Policy Cover Consequential Damages?
November 11, 2019 | Construction Law, Insurance Coverage
Interview With Laurence Midler
November 1, 2019 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance
The Negligent Breach of Contract Problem In Liability Insurance
September 30, 2019 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance
Privilege and Work Product in Insurance Coverage Disputes
September 3, 2019 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance
No Zebra or Leopard Prints: Insurance Company Must Repair Buildings to Match
August 26, 2019 | Construction Law, Policyholder Protection, Claims
Bucking Modern Trend, Ohio Supreme Court Refuses to Reconsider Whether Defective Construction Work Can Be a Fortuitous ‘Occurrence’
July 3, 2019 | Construction Law, Construction Defects, Subcontractors, Appeals
‘Sudden and Accidental’ Discharges May Avoid the Pollution Exclusion
May 28, 2019 | Environmental, Policyholder Protection, Remediation, Commercial General Liability
‘Sudden and Accidental’ Discharges May Avoid the Pollution Exclusion
May 28, 2019 | Environmental, Policyholder Protection, Remediation, Commercial General Liability
Noise and the Decision to Settle Within Insurance Policy Limits
May 16, 2019 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance
Insurance Coverage for California Companies for Employee Sexual Misconduct Claims
May 3, 2019 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance
Municipalities Beware: Inverse Condemnation Exclusions May Affect Coverage
January 17, 2019 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance, Policy
CGL Insurer Ordered to Pay Purely Economic Loss
December 21, 2018 | Policyholder Protection, Insurance
Is a Settlement of a Restitution Claim Covered If Your Policy’s Ill-Gotten Gains Exclusion Applies Only In the Event of a Final Adjudication?
June 11, 2018 | Indiana Insurance Coverage, Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Eleventh Circuit Reaches Different Conclusions While Examining Pollution Exclusion
May 29, 2018 | Indiana Insurance Coverage, Policyholder Protection
Minnesota Court of Appeals Confirms Agent Comments Can Bind Insurer
May 25, 2018 | Indiana Insurance Coverage, Policyholder Protection
Upcoming Webinar: Insurance Coverage for Opioid Litigation and Lessons for Other Types of Claims
May 17, 2018 | Claims, Webinar, Policyholder Protection
The Tenth Circuit Hands Another Win to Policyholders Seeking to Insure Defective Workmanship By Their Subcontractors
February 27, 2018 | Occurrence, Policy, Policyholder Protection
Avoid Insurance Related Risks to Help Your Bottom Line
January 25, 2018 | Cyber Insurance, Insurance, Risk Management, Policyholder Protection
New Year’s Resolutions for Policyholders
January 9, 2018 | Insurance, Policy, Policyholder Protection
Sold! Close Your M&A Deal Confidently by Funding Post-Closing Liabilities Through Insurance
January 2, 2018 | do, Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Payback: Can Settlements of False Claims Act Claims Be Covered Under D&O Policies?
December 26, 2017 | do, Insurance, Policyholder Protection
When Should an Accident be an Accident?
November 27, 2017 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Tenth Circuit Holds that Governmental Investigation of Potential Criminal Violations is Not a ‘Claim’ Under a D&O Policy
November 15, 2017 | do, Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Four Things to Know About Certificates of Insurance
October 9, 2017 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Back to School: Time to Revisit the Basic Principles of Business Interruption Coverage
August 29, 2017 | Indiana Insurance Coverage, Natural Disaster, Policyholder Protection
Is a Claimant’s Misnomer the Be-All, End-All in an Insurance Coverage Dispute?
July 13, 2017 | Indiana Insurance Coverage, Policyholder Protection
Get Smart About Additional Insured Endorsements: Beware of the Proximate Cause Standard Recently Adopted in New York
June 26, 2017 | Additional Insured, Policyholder Protection
Why Indemnification Provisions are Important
June 2, 2017 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Check Your Policy When an Insurer Says a Self-Insured Retention Applies to Its Duty to Defend
May 30, 2017 | Duty To Defend, Policyholder Protection
Bad Faith Isn’t the Only Remedy
March 27, 2017 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Coverage for Commotion: Insurance for Businesses Affected By Rioting and Vandalism
February 8, 2017 | Insurance, Natural Disaster, Policyholder Protection
California Supreme Court Denies Insurance Industry’s Attempt to Deregulate Insurance in California
February 7, 2017 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Recent Trial Win Raises Interesting Issues on Relationship Between Insurance Agent and Policyholder
January 30, 2017 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Franchisors: Don’t Forget About Insurance for Joint Employer Liability Claims
January 27, 2017 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Exercise Your Bargaining Power at Renewal Time
November 28, 2016 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
When the Damage is Done Are You Prepared to Litigate Against Your Insurance Company?
October 11, 2016 | Insurance, Insurance Broker Claims, Policyholder Protection
Upcoming Webinar on Aug. 23: What Keeps You Up At Night?
August 17, 2016 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Insurance, Indemnification, and Limitation of Liability Provisions in Business Contracts
August 8, 2016 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
In Determining Duty to Defend, Wisconsin Supreme Court Clarifies Four-Corners Rule
July 12, 2016 | Duty To Defend, Policyholder Protection
Georgia Supreme Court Expands Scope of Absolute Pollution Exclusion
May 12, 2016 | Commercial General Liability, Policyholder Protection
Are You Prepared for a Natural Disaster?
March 25, 2016 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Will The Fourth Circuit Overturn a Decision Finding CGL Coverage For a Data Breach?
March 24, 2016 | Data Breach, Policyholder Protection
Capitalizing on Sites with Environmental Property Damage: Is there really a pot of gold at the end of that rainbow?
March 15, 2016 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Join us: Insurance Considerations in Mergers and Acquisitions
March 7, 2016 | Insurance, Miscellaneous, Policyholder Protection
Sing The Jingle: Four Tips Inspired By Insurance Ads
March 3, 2016 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Andy Detherage and Charlie Edwards present Lessons from a Recent $204 Million Jury Verdict Against 17 Insurers
December 16, 2015 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Barnes & Thornburg Bronze Sponsor of the 2015 ABA Women in Litigation Conference
November 20, 2015 | Claims, Insurance, Policyholder Protection
2.4 Million Reasons to Monitor Claim Costs: Five Lessons From a Barnes & Thornburg Victory
November 16, 2015 | Claims, Policyholder Protection
You Snooze; You Lose: When The Carrier’s “Investigation” (Read: Delay) Breaches The Duty To Defend
October 28, 2015 | Duty To Defend, Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Now available for viewing - Insurance Law Webinar: You’re Covered, But...
September 8, 2015 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Louisiana Federal Court Finds in Favor of Coverage for Work Required by Clean Air Act Consent Decree
August 28, 2015 | Policy, Policyholder Protection
PENNSYLVANIA HIGH COURT EXPANDS CIRCUMSTANCES UNDER WHICH INSUREDS MAY SETTLE UNDERLYING CLAIMS WITHOUT INSURER CONSENT
August 26, 2015 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Join Us for an Insurance Law Webinar: You're Covered, But...
August 4, 2015 | Miscellaneous, Policyholder Protection
Five Tips: Insurance Fundamentals for In-House Counsel
July 15, 2015 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Scott Godes Quoted in Law360 Article, “4 Insurance Takeaways from Lloyd’s Cyberattack Report"
July 14, 2015 | Cyber Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Indiana Supreme Court Sets Up Future Coverage Battles Over Allocation, Defense Costs
June 15, 2015 | Indiana Insurance Coverage, Insurance, Policyholder Protection
INFRINGEMENT OF “SLOGAN” TRIGGERS THE DUTY TO DEFEND
June 11, 2015 | Duty To Defend, Policyholder Protection
Are we seeing a revival in Michigan environmental insurance coverage?
June 5, 2015 | Insurance, Miscellaneous, Policyholder Protection
Settlement Means Policyholders Will Have to Wait for Clarification of Proper Exhaustion Issue
May 18, 2015 | Excess Insurance, Policyholder Protection
YOU WANT MORE THAN 'FULL COVERAGE'
April 24, 2015 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Best Practices in Managing Insurance Claims
April 17, 2015 | Claims, Policyholder Protection
Ken Gorenberg to speak at Chicago Bar Association seminar, “Insurance and Risk Management for Corporate Transactions”
April 15, 2015 | Insurance, Risk Management, Policyholder Protection
Recent Decision Determines Retail Displays May Qualify as ‘Advertisements’ Under CGL Insurance Policies
March 20, 2015 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Godes Quoted in Law360 Article: 5 Tips For Navigating 'Wild West' Of Cyber Policies
March 19, 2015 | Cyber Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Barnes & Thornburg Represents Simon Property Group in $200 Million Summary Judgment Victory
March 18, 2015 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
RECENT CASE LAW ILLUSTRATES IMPORTANCE OF WORDING FOR “FINAL ADJUDICATION” REQUIREMENT IN D&O EXCLUSIONS
February 18, 2015 | do, Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Eleventh Circuit Decision Epitomizes the Differing Standards of Justice Received by Insureds in State Versus Federal Courts
February 13, 2015 | Claims, Insurance, Policyholder Protection
2014 Year in Review
January 28, 2015 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Did the Supreme Court just make removal easier for insurance companies?
January 21, 2015 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
2014 Year in Review: A National Insurance Recovery Webinar
January 9, 2015 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Scott Godes quoted in, “Insurers cover fraction of costs in Catholic dioceses’ clergy abuse cases”
January 6, 2015 | Insurance, Policyholder Protection
COVERAGE FOR “DISPARAGEMENT”: A POWERFUL TOOL FOR TRIGGERING THE DUTY TO DEFEND IN BUSINESS DISPUTES
December 18, 2014 | Duty To Defend, Policyholder Protection
Thankful for Our Policyholder Clients and Insurance Professional Colleagues
November 26, 2014 | Miscellaneous, Policyholder Protection
Do We Have Coverage for This? Sometimes it's worth getting a second opinion
November 25, 2014 | Claims, Policyholder Protection
SOFT INSURANCE MARKET
November 24, 2014 | do, Policyholder Protection
Scott Godes to Present at the Comprehensive Conference on Cybersecurity Law Presented by Law Seminars International
November 20, 2014 | Cyber Insurance, Policyholder Protection
Scott Godes to Speak About Insurance Coverage for Asbestos Claims at ACI’s 18th National Advanced Forum on Asbestos Claims & Litigation
November 17, 2014 | Claims, Policyholder Protection
Discovery Warnings From In Re Hurricane Sandy Cases
November 13, 2014 | Discovery, Policyholder Protection
Know Your Rights: Policyholders’ Defense and Settlement Rights
November 4, 2014 | Claims, Policyholder Protection
Scott Godes Elected to American College of Coverage and Extracontractual Counsel (ACCEC)
October 31, 2014 | Miscellaneous, Policyholder Protection
(E)stop, Hey, What’s That Sound? Insurers Get What’s Going Down
September 23, 2014 | Additional Insured, Policyholder Protection
Join us Sept. 25 for Barnes & Thornburg’s National Insurance Recovery Seminar
September 18, 2014 | Miscellaneous, Policyholder Protection
Personal and Advertising Injury Coverage Is Fertile Ground for Policyholders
June 27, 2014 | Claims, Policyholder Protection
"Race to the Courthouse" Forum Shopping Strategy
June 13, 2014 | Indiana Insurance Coverage, Policyholder Protection
RELATED PRACTICE AREAS
Subscribe
Do you want to receive more valuable insights directly in your inbox? Visit our subscription center and let us know what you're interested in learning more about.
View Subscription Center