A little white lie never hurt anyone, right? That age-old saying appears to be false, at least when it comes to a recent ruling by the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB). On June 9, the NLRB issued its decision in Cellco Partnership, 365 NLRB No. 93 (2017), which found that an employer unlawfully discharged an employee for dishonesty because the employer had handled terminations for lying inconsistently. In the case, employee Bianca Cunningham, a known union activist, was asked by another employee, Victory Esharetur, for advice about a workplace issue. Specifically, Esharetur had concerns about staying late with a manager in light of a disagreement she’d had with the manager earlier in the day, saying she felt threatened. Cunningham told Esharetur that if she were to feel threatened and find herself in the same situation, she would “go home.” So that is exactly what Esharetur did; she clocked out and left work without authorization. During its investigation into Esharetur’s unauthorized departure from work, the company interviewed Cunningham multiple times. While Cunningham initially denied ever telling Esharetur to leave work, she subsequently admitted to investigators that she had told Esharetur she would leave if she ever found herself in that type of situation. Cunningham also had some inconsistencies in statements she made regarding the nature of text message exchanges with Esharetur about the incident. The employer considered Cunningham’s inconsistent statements to constitute lying during an investigation and terminated her on that basis. The company, however, had not consistently terminated other employees who had lied during investigations. An NLRB administrative law judge (ALJ) determined the company unlawfully discharged Cunningham based on her union activity. The ALJ largely cited how the company had been inconsistent in its treatment of other employees who had lied during past investigations. That is, the ALJ inferred union animus by the employer in light of the fact that other employees engaging in dishonesty who were not known union supporters retained their employment, whereas Cunningham – a vocal union supporter – was discharged. The NLRB affirmed the ALJ’s decision in its June 9 opinion. In addition to ordering backpay, the NLRB also required the company to pay subsequent job-search costs/expenses to Cunningham, which aligns with the agency’s new approach on this front. This case illustrates the importance of being consistent when it comes to employee discipline. While union activity does not give an employee carte blanche to engage in misconduct, terminating an employee who has engaged in protected activity could be invalidated if a company’s treatment of that type of misconduct has been inconsistent.
‘BIG Little Lies’: Employer’s Inconsistent Practice Invalidates Employee Termination for Dishonesty, Says NLRB
David J. Pryzbylski
PartnerRELATED ARTICLES
Labor Law Changes To Be Aware Of In The New Year
January 3, 2023 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
Mailing It In? Labor Board Signals Potential Return To Manual Elections
October 3, 2022 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership
Not So FAST…Blocking California’s New Fast Food Industry Union Giveaway
September 12, 2022 | Labor Relations, State Labor Laws, Currents - Employment Law
NLRB Proposes Rescinding Trump Board Rule and Expanding Definition of ‘Joint Employer’
September 8, 2022 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
Order Up! California Governor Signs Fast Food Accountability Law Aimed at Larger Fast Food Operations
September 7, 2022 | Labor Relations, State Labor Laws, Currents - Employment Law
Labor Law Changes To Be Aware Of In The New Year
January 3, 2023 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
Mailing It In? Labor Board Signals Potential Return To Manual Elections
October 3, 2022 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership
Not So FAST…Blocking California’s New Fast Food Industry Union Giveaway
September 12, 2022 | Labor Relations, State Labor Laws, Currents - Employment Law
NLRB Proposes Rescinding Trump Board Rule and Expanding Definition of ‘Joint Employer’
September 8, 2022 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
Order Up! California Governor Signs Fast Food Accountability Law Aimed at Larger Fast Food Operations
September 7, 2022 | Labor Relations, State Labor Laws, Currents - Employment Law
Federal Court Orders Starbucks to Re-Hire Terminated Union Supporters
August 23, 2022 | Labor Relations, Unions and Union Membership
Classifying Workers as Independent Contractors May Soon Become More Complicated
July 18, 2022 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
Shorthanded: Labor Board Faces Challenges In Handling Influx of Cases
May 9, 2022 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board, Union Organizing
Labor Law Remedies: Back Pay, Front Pay, And … Training?
May 2, 2022 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
What’s Brewing at Starbucks? Labor Law Litigation Over Employee Terminations
April 26, 2022 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board, Union Organizing
Caffeine Rush: Union Organizing Wave at Starbucks Continues
March 2, 2022 | Labor Relations, Union Organizing
Unions by the Numbers: 2022 Edition
January 24, 2022 | Labor Relations, Unions and Union Membership, Union Organizing
Abruzzo's Tweets Take Aim at Employer-Friendly Labor Law Precedent
December 8, 2021 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership
Fast Times at the NLRB: The Labor Board Targets Spicoli
November 12, 2021 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership
Prepare for Takeoff: NLRB’s New Pro-Union Majority Will Soon Take Over
July 30, 2021 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
Un-Exterminated: Scabby the Rat Is Back, Says Labor Board
July 29, 2021 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board, Strikes and Picketing, Unions and Union Membership
Buckle Up, Employers: PRO Act Passes the House
March 11, 2021 | Labor Relations, Federal Laws and Legislation, Union Organizing
Acting NLRB General Counsel Rescinds 10 Trump-Era Guidance Memos
February 16, 2021 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
What Is The PRO Act And Should Your Company Be Concerned?
February 4, 2021 | Labor Relations, Federal Laws and Legislation, Union Organizing
What Were the Three Biggest Labor Law Developments In 2020?
December 18, 2020 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
A Biden Board at the NLRB: What to Expect and When
November 17, 2020 | Labor Relations, Federal Laws and Legislation, National Labor Relations Board
Yet Another 2020 Labor Law Oddity: Employer Lockouts Fall Precipitously
November 2, 2020 | Labor Relations
Does Labor Law Protect Employees Engaged In Political or Social Advocacy?
October 14, 2020 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
Oh Snap! Employee Lawfully Terminated For Profanity-Laced Facebook Post
August 18, 2020 | Labor Relations, Social Media and Technology, National Labor Relations Board
NLRB Offers Some Pandemic Labor Law Clarity
August 12, 2020 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership
Can You Have Policies Allowing Searches Of Employee Emails And Personal Vehicles?
July 22, 2020 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
Big Changes to California’s Garment Industry Possible
July 9, 2020 | Labor Relations, State Labor Laws
Labor Law Considerations As You Restart Your Business
May 8, 2020 | Labor Relations, Unions and Union Membership, Federal Laws and Legislation
Ouch: Union Dinged By Federal Court for Disrespectful Remarks to Resigning Member
April 20, 2020 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership
Can You Conduct Collective Bargaining By Phone or Teleconference In the Age of Coronavirus?
March 26, 2020 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
Do You Have To Bargain With Your Union Over Your Coronavirus Response Measures?
March 19, 2020 | Labor Relations, Unions and Union Membership
Ouch! Company Ordered To Reopen, Rehire Illegally Fired Employees
March 10, 2020 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board, Union Organizing
Just a Reminder: Your Employees May be Recording You
February 13, 2020 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
NLRB Continues To Validate Employee Confidentiality Provisions
February 7, 2020 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
Show Me The Money! CNN To Pay $76 Million To Resolve Labor Board Complaints
January 22, 2020 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership
Labor Board Rounds Out 2019 with a Few More Obama-Era Reversals
January 6, 2020 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership
NLRB Squares Itself With EEOC: Employers May Require Confidentiality During Open Investigations
December 18, 2019 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
Can You Spy on Your Employees' Private Facebook Group?
November 1, 2019 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
Is Fighting With Coworkers Protected Activity?
July 17, 2019 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board, Union Organizing
What Happened To Former NLRB Chairman Mark Gaston Pearce?
July 1, 2019 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
Don’t Take The Bait! Termination Of Employee Provoked By Employer’s Negative Review Unlawful
June 7, 2019 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
Thin Skin? Discharge of Employee for Criticizing Executive’s Salary Was Unlawful
May 31, 2019 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
Can You Terminate An Employee For Talking To The Press?
April 24, 2019 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
NLRB GC Action May Make Unions More Accountable To Their Members
October 26, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Does Enrolling In E-Verify Violate Labor Law?
September 7, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Don’t Pull The Tapes: Employer Dinged By NLRB For Surveilling Employee Union Activity On Video Archives
July 23, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Janus Decided: Supreme Court Invalidates Mandatory Public Union Fees
June 27, 2018 | Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
UAW Sues Over UAW-Chrysler National Training Center Scandal
June 12, 2018 | Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Teamsters On The Hook For Full Back Pay, Says NLRB
June 7, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Fractured Workforce: Union Scores Micro-Unit Election Win At Boeing
June 4, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Don’t Pick and Choose: Company’s Inconsistent Rules Enforcement Results in Employee Terminations Being Overturned
May 2, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Does Misclassifying Employees As Independent Contractors Violate Labor Law?
February 19, 2018 | Department of Labor, National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Columbia to Fight NLRB Ruling on Graduate Assistants’ Unionization Efforts in Federal Court
January 31, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Kentucky’s Right-to-Work Law Upheld by Court
January 26, 2018 | State Labor Laws, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
CLOSED: NLRB Among Agencies Closed During Government Shutdown
January 22, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Potential Organizational Changes at the NLRB Could Drastically Affect Labor Board Case Handling
January 19, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Trump Fills Final Vacancy on NLRB, Returns NLRB to Republican-Led Majority
January 19, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Welcome to the NLRB Labor Law Time Machine, Step Right In…
December 19, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
And So It Begins…Trump NLRB Overturns Obama NLRB Precedent for First Time
December 12, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Employers Face the Music: NLRB Judge Rules Musicians May Protest Outside Auditorium
December 11, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Unions Struggling to Negotiate Wage Increases on Par With 2016
November 20, 2017 | Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Survey Says: Incentive-Based Pay Systems Provide Higher Compensation Than Time-Based Models
October 16, 2017 | Labor Agreements, Labor Relations
There’s a Hole in Your Bucket: 114 Multiemployer Pension Funds on Track to Fail
August 23, 2017 | Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Union Corruption: UAW and Auto Manufacturer Officials Allegedly Embezzled Millions in Union-Member Funds
August 11, 2017 | Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
‘Absurd Results’: NLRB Takes 'Facebook Discipline Cases' to New Heights (Or New Lows, Depending on Your Point of View)
July 31, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Negotiating Tips: The Art of the Ratification Bonus
June 23, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Untangling the Web? Senator Introduces Bill to Reverse Obama-Era Ambush Union Election Rules
June 21, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
‘Let’s Get Ready To Rumble!’ Class Action Waiver Battle Kicks Off At Supreme Court
June 15, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Congressional Leaders Ask Trump to Fill Long-Standing Vacancies at the NLRB
June 7, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
‘Smile, You’re On Candid Camera’ – Federal Court Upholds NLRB Ruling That Prohibits Non-Union Employers From Banning Recordings in the Workplace
June 5, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
A Growing Divide: Sixth Circuit Decision To Invalidate Class/Collective Action Waiver Widens Appellate Court Split
May 31, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Senator Introduces Bill To Amend NLRA And Reverse Micro-Unit Trend
May 26, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Getting Away With Murder? NLRB Tells Federal Court Union Election Observer’s Use Of Fake Firearm Did NOT Invalidate Union Election Results
May 25, 2017 | Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
It Could Be. It Might Be. IT IS! DOL’s Persuader Rule To Be GONE!
May 24, 2017 | Department of Labor, Labor Relations
Trump Appoints Miscimarra as Chairman of NLRB
April 26, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Union Body Count and Big Spending
April 21, 2017 | Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
A Dancer With an Attitude? Fired Vegas Show Dancer Pursues Workers’ Rights
April 7, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Sixth Circuit Refuses to Vacate; Lets Local Municipal Right-To-Work Decision Stand
March 16, 2017 | State Labor Laws, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Seattle Legal Battles Mount: Uber Drivers and U.S. Chamber Fight Driver Unionization Law
March 15, 2017 | Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
The Legality of Local Municipal Right-to-Work Laws; Will A Circuit Split Lead To Supreme Court Review
March 14, 2017 | Federal Laws and Legislation, Labor Relations
'Show Your Face' – IBEW Restrictions On Union Resignation and Dues Checkoff In Right-to-Work States Found Unlawful
February 15, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Missouri Adopts Right-to-Work, Are the Feds Next?
February 9, 2017 | Federal Laws and Legislation, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Second Persuader Rule Case Halted; Court to Wait for New Administration
December 9, 2016 | Federal Laws and Legislation, Labor Relations
NLRB Member Kent Y. Hirozawa’s Term Expires – But He Left His Mark On U.S. Labor Law
September 7, 2016 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Down Goes Brown – NLRB Finds Graduate Assistants May Unionize
August 23, 2016 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Federal Court Strikes Down Part of Georgia’s Right to Work Law
July 13, 2016 | Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Fifth Circuit Agrees NLRB Micro-Unit Test Here to Stay
June 9, 2016 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Are Permanent Replacements Permanent Anymore?
June 3, 2016 | National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
AFL-CIO to Challenge West Virginia Right to Work Law
May 10, 2016 | Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
GOP Moves to Block New Persuader Rule
April 18, 2016 | Union Organizing, Labor Relations
‘Tis The Season: Unions Continue To Spend Significant Amounts Of Employees’ Dues Money On Political Causes
April 7, 2016 | Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Browning-Ferris “All In” On Joint Employer Battle With NLRB
January 15, 2016 | Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
When Will the Other Shoe Drop? NLRB May Hand Down Second Blow after Browning-Ferris
September 30, 2015 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Employer Dinged for Unlawful Interrogation and Confiscating Union Literature Immediately Following Break Period; Vindicated for Simultaneous Leafletting
September 10, 2015 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
The Hits Keep On Coming: NLRB Ruling Makes It Easier For Unions To Establish “Joint-Employers” Under The NLRA
August 31, 2015 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Amazon Settlement with NLRB a Reminder for Employers -- "Confidential" Wage Policies Violate the NLRA
November 25, 2014 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
NLRB Again Overturns Discharge Of Employee Who Engaged In A Profanity-Laced Argument With A Manager In Front Of Customers
June 18, 2014 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Some Hope for Employers? Limits on Alan Ritchey Discretionary Discipline Bargaining Obligation Applied by NLRB
June 13, 2014 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
NLRB Continues To Impose Expansive Penalties On Employers
April 29, 2014 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
BTLabor Relations Blogger & Attorney Fields Questions on College Football Players Union Ruling
March 28, 2014 | National Labor Relations Board, Union Organizing, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
NLRB Directs Election at Northwestern – Scholarship Football Players are Employees
March 26, 2014 | National Labor Relations Board, Union Organizing, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
NLRB Chairman signals willingness to reverse Register Guard decision
March 24, 2014 | National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Football is a "Year-round Gig": The Briefs are in on Unionizing College Athletes
March 21, 2014 | Union Organizing, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Law on Unionization of Home Care Workers Continues to Shift
March 20, 2014 | Labor Relations, Unions and Union Membership
New Michigan Right to Work Lawsuit Filed After MEA Threatens to Send Teacher to Collections for Failing to Pay Dues
March 10, 2014 | State Labor Laws, Labor Relations
A “Hail Mary”? Northwestern Student-Athletes File Union Petition with the NLRB
January 29, 2014 | National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Employee’s Complaint About Union Officials Watching Porn is Deemed “Human Imperfection” But Not Grounds for Retaliation
January 15, 2014 | Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
RELATED PRACTICE AREAS
Subscribe
Do you want to receive more valuable insights directly in your inbox? Visit our subscription center and let us know what you're interested in learning more about.
View Subscription Center