Page is loading...
Print Logo Logo

Pennsylvania Supreme Court “Considers” Noncompetes: Mere Continued Employment Not Enough

Bill Nolan

William A. Nolan

Columbus Managing Partner

In what has been a remarkable run of state supreme court cases out of the heartland addressing the question of what consideration will be sufficient to support a noncompete, yesterday the Pennsylvania Supreme Court came down on the anti-enforcement side of this question, holding that any restriction on employment requires some additional benefit beyond continued employment. In other words, an employer cannot hand a noncompete to a long-term employee and have it be enforceable unless the employer provides some additional value to the employee. Pennsylvania thereby joins Illinois and Kentucky as states in which recent decisions have held that mere continuing employment is insufficient to support a noncompete. In contrast, most recently Wisconsin took a more pro-enforcement view, holding that continued employment was consideration. The Pennsylvania decision may be read here.

What consideration supports noncompetes is one of two key variables in state laws relating to noncompetes, and probably the trickier of the two.  (The other is the extent to which a court will modify a noncompete to make it reasonable.) As discussed in the Wisconsin article linked above, employers need to be aware of the law in states where they might be “competed with,” regardless of what their noncompete agreement may say about choice of law because other states’ courts often will not observe the parties’ choice of law. If you do business in Pennsylvania, or you have competitors competing with you from Pennsylvania, make sure you talk to experienced legal counsel about your noncompete program to make sure you are properly accounting for all of the recent judicial activity on this key issue.

P.S.  As I have suggested here before, probably do not take too seriously the articles likely to follow declaring this to be the most recent step in the death of noncompetes.  Not likely.


12 Days of Handbook Updates: Non-Competes

December 20, 2023 | Labor and Employment, High Stakes Employment Issues, Non-competes and Trade Secrets

Labor Board’s Top Lawyer Declares Most Non-Compete Agreements Violate Labor Law

June 1, 2023 | Labor and Employment, National Labor Relations Board, Federal Laws and Legislation

Crosshairs: Labor Board Targets Gig Economy, Non-Compete Agreements, and More

July 26, 2022 | Labor and Employment, National Labor Relations Board


Do you want to receive more valuable insights directly in your inbox? Visit our subscription center and let us know what you're interested in learning more about.

View Subscription Center
Trending Connect
We use cookies on this site to enhance your user experience. By clicking any link on this page you are giving your consent for us to use cookies.