The parties have now submitted briefing on the question of whether the College Athletes Players Association (“CAPA”) can organize a bargaining unit comprised of Northwestern University college football players and students. Specifically the briefs, which can be accessed here and here, debate whether CAPA is an appropriate labor representative and whether the students are actually employees within the meaning of the National Labor Relations Act. CAPA’s brief argues that the students “perform valuable services for Northwestern University. They have substantial football-related responsibilities year-round, performed under the strict supervision and control of the Northwestern coaches and Athletic Department staff. Their football activities are separate from the players’ academic pursuits as students at the University. In return for their football services, the players are compensated by the University through scholarships . . .” CAPA argues that “this case is not about how much money Northwestern makes from football, or whether Northwestern is a good employer, or whether the compensation provided to the players is fair. Nor is it about the quality of the education that the players receive at Northwestern. Indeed, the players view Northwestern as a good employer. They appreciate that they receive an excellent education and they take pride in the academic success they achieve while performing what amounts to a full-time job for Northwestern’s football program. But an employee is an employee, whether his compensation is generous or parsimonious, whether he has excellent or tenuous job security, and whether his employer is enlightened or unreasonable. If the employee provides services for and at the direction of the employer and is compensated for doing so, the employee is an employee, and is entitled to the rights and protections of the Act.” Northwestern’s brief contends that the players are students first and not employees. “At Northwestern, academics always trump athletics. The University’s student-athletes, even those who are recruited and receive athletic scholarships to participate on the football team, do so in order to receive a world-class education. Northwestern is well aware that a student who chooses to participate in its football program faces challenges on and off the field. But meeting those challenges is part of the education that Northwestern seeks to provide, and part of shaping the class Northwestern aspires to graduate.” The athletes have a “predominantly academic, rather than economic, relationship with the University” and as a result are students and not employees. While CAPA argues that the students are actually employees under the Supreme Court’s test in NLRB v. Town & Country, Inc., 516 U.S. 85, 90 (1995) (the definition of ‘employee’ [is] any ‘person who works for another in return for financial or other compensation’”), the central legal issue centers around the viability of Brown University, 342 NLRB 463 (2004). In Brown, the NLRB found graduate assistant teachers not to be employees because their teaching duties were an integral part of their post-graduate degree program. In fact, in CAPA’s brief, while it denies the applicability of Brown, the association nonetheless argues that the NLRB should overturn that Bush era decision. Instead, CAPA argues, the Board should apply the Obama era precedent in New York University, 356 NLRB No. 7 (2010).
Football is a "Year-round Gig": The Briefs are in on Unionizing College Athletes
Gerald F. Lutkus
Of Counsel (Retired)RELATED ARTICLES
Unnecessary Roughness: NLRB Calls Foul on Union for Workplace Investigation Interference
June 17, 2020 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership
Ouch: Union Dinged By Federal Court for Disrespectful Remarks to Resigning Member
April 20, 2020 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership
Union Violated Labor Law By Refusing To Provide Information On How To Resign
January 9, 2020 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership
Final Exam? NLRB to AGAIN Address Whether Grad Students are Employees
September 23, 2019 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
Uh-Oh: Company’s Social Media Policy Ruled Unlawful
September 18, 2019 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
Unnecessary Roughness: NLRB Calls Foul on Union for Workplace Investigation Interference
June 17, 2020 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership
Ouch: Union Dinged By Federal Court for Disrespectful Remarks to Resigning Member
April 20, 2020 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership
Union Violated Labor Law By Refusing To Provide Information On How To Resign
January 9, 2020 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership
Final Exam? NLRB to AGAIN Address Whether Grad Students are Employees
September 23, 2019 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
Uh-Oh: Company’s Social Media Policy Ruled Unlawful
September 18, 2019 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
The Dizzying World of Worker Classification Just Got Slightly Less Harrowing
September 3, 2019 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
NLRB Announces New Standard for Off-Duty Onsite Contractors' Access to Property
August 27, 2019 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
Ouch! Harm to Business or Reputation Policy Ruled Unlawful
August 23, 2019 | Labor Relations, National Labor Relations Board
Planes, Trains, and No Collusion!
June 13, 2019 | Labor Relations, Federal Laws and Legislation
NLRB GC Action May Make Unions More Accountable To Their Members
October 26, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Reckless Driving: Employee Discharge For Antics On Public Highway Upheld
October 5, 2018 | Strikes and Picketing, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Is That A Section 9(a) Or 8(f) Agreement? The NLRB May Soon Be Providing More Clarity.
September 13, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Does Enrolling In E-Verify Violate Labor Law?
September 7, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
When Do Employee Weingarten Rights Kick In?
August 17, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
No Soliciting: Employer Solicitation Ban Ruled Unlawful
August 9, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Changes Coming to NLRB’s Stance On Company E-Mail Policies?
August 2, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Don’t Pull The Tapes: Employer Dinged By NLRB For Surveilling Employee Union Activity On Video Archives
July 23, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Janus Decided: Supreme Court Invalidates Mandatory Public Union Fees
June 27, 2018 | Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Happiest Union On Earth? Teamsters Violated Disney Parks Workers’ Labor Law Rights
June 25, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
UAW Sues Over UAW-Chrysler National Training Center Scandal
June 12, 2018 | Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Fractured Workforce: Union Scores Micro-Unit Election Win At Boeing
June 4, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Whose Law Is It Anyway? NLRB Dings Company For Actions Related To FLSA (Not NLRA) Lawsuit
March 22, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Another Redo At The NLRB Because Of Conflicts of Interest?
March 16, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Full Disclosure: Hospital Forced To Give Union Confidential Business Information
March 13, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Does Labor Law Protect Employees Engaged In Harassment?
March 7, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Justified: Labor Board Upholds Discharge Of Employee Who Misused Company Security Passcode
March 6, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
U.S. Supreme Court to Take Up Independent Contractor Arbitration Case
February 27, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Oh no! It’s Back: NLRB’s Browning-Ferris Decision Reinstated
February 26, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Does Misclassifying Employees As Independent Contractors Violate Labor Law?
February 19, 2018 | Department of Labor, National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Prior Administration Board Decisions Still Matter
February 16, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Can You Require Employees To Keep Harassment And Other Workplace Investigations “Confidential”?
February 7, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
On the Hook: NLRB Forces Hotel to Pay Union’s Attorney’s Fees Related to Boycott Spat
February 5, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Second Time’s the Charm? NLRB to Reconsider Lawfulness of Restaurant’s Work Rules Under New Standard
February 1, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Columbia to Fight NLRB Ruling on Graduate Assistants’ Unionization Efforts in Federal Court
January 31, 2018 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Kentucky’s Right-to-Work Law Upheld by Court
January 26, 2018 | State Labor Laws, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
And So It Begins…Trump NLRB Overturns Obama NLRB Precedent for First Time
December 12, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
DOL Head Slams NLRB’s Vague Test for Joint Employment
November 21, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Unions Struggling to Negotiate Wage Increases on Par With 2016
November 20, 2017 | Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
NLRB Protected Concerted Activity or Harassment – Will Employers Finally Get Clarity?
November 14, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Action! House Passes Legislation to Stave Off Broadening Definition of Joint Employment
November 8, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Survey Says: Incentive-Based Pay Systems Provide Higher Compensation Than Time-Based Models
October 16, 2017 | Labor Agreements, Labor Relations
Will Congress Act to Stave Off the Broadening Definition of Joint Employment?
October 6, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
NBA Team’s Electronic Display Operators are Employees, Not Independent Contractors, Says NLRB
August 22, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
A Nice Change of Pace: NLRB Upholds Employer’s Confidential Information Policy
August 15, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
‘Absurd Results’: NLRB Takes 'Facebook Discipline Cases' to New Heights (Or New Lows, Depending on Your Point of View)
July 31, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Woo-hoo! Federal Court Overrules NLRB, Says Companies Can Require Employees to Promote Positivity
July 26, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Playing Hardball – NLRB Holds High School Lacrosse Referees Are Employees, Not Independent Contractors
July 12, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Eighth Circuit Sides With Jimmy John’s and Finds Employee Actions Were Not Protected Activity
July 7, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Negotiating Tips: The Art of the Ratification Bonus
June 23, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Take a Screen Shot of This: Supervisor Unlawfully Interrogated Employee Through Text, NLRB Says
June 23, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Untangling the Web? Senator Introduces Bill to Reverse Obama-Era Ambush Union Election Rules
June 21, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Fahrenheit 180: DOJ Reverses Course, Abandons NLRB at Supreme Court in Class Action Fight
June 19, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
‘Let’s Get Ready To Rumble!’ Class Action Waiver Battle Kicks Off At Supreme Court
June 15, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
‘BIG Little Lies’: Employer’s Inconsistent Practice Invalidates Employee Termination for Dishonesty, Says NLRB
June 13, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
‘Smile, You’re On Candid Camera’ – Federal Court Upholds NLRB Ruling That Prohibits Non-Union Employers From Banning Recordings in the Workplace
June 5, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Senator Introduces Bill To Amend NLRA And Reverse Micro-Unit Trend
May 26, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
It Could Be. It Might Be. IT IS! DOL’s Persuader Rule To Be GONE!
May 24, 2017 | Department of Labor, Labor Relations
First-Year Report Card on Graduate Student Assistants Unionization
May 19, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Another Overreach? NLRB Finds Company Violated the NLRA by Retaliating Against Former Employee for Filing FLSA (Not NLRA) Class Action
May 18, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Union Body Count and Big Spending
April 21, 2017 | Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
NLRB Invalidates Another Employer Arbitration Agreement – But NOT Under D.R. Horton
April 17, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
A Dancer With an Attitude? Fired Vegas Show Dancer Pursues Workers’ Rights
April 7, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Sixth Circuit Refuses to Vacate; Lets Local Municipal Right-To-Work Decision Stand
March 16, 2017 | State Labor Laws, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Seattle Legal Battles Mount: Uber Drivers and U.S. Chamber Fight Driver Unionization Law
March 15, 2017 | Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
The Legality of Local Municipal Right-to-Work Laws; Will A Circuit Split Lead To Supreme Court Review
March 14, 2017 | Federal Laws and Legislation, Labor Relations
'Show Your Face' – IBEW Restrictions On Union Resignation and Dues Checkoff In Right-to-Work States Found Unlawful
February 15, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Missouri Adopts Right-to-Work, Are the Feds Next?
February 9, 2017 | Federal Laws and Legislation, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Will Seattle Uber Drivers Really Be Able to Unionize? Uber Takes Legal Action to Halt City Rules
January 23, 2017 | State Labor Laws, Labor Relations
U.S. Supreme Court to Decide D.R. Horton Arbitration Waiver Issue
January 13, 2017 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
NLRB Affirms Decision Finding Charter Schools Subject to NLRA
November 23, 2016 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
NLRB Member Kent Y. Hirozawa’s Term Expires – But He Left His Mark On U.S. Labor Law
September 7, 2016 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
NLRB: Is Misclassification of Independent Contractors an Unfair Labor Practice?
August 31, 2016 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Down Goes Brown – NLRB Finds Graduate Assistants May Unionize
August 23, 2016 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Federal Court Strikes Down Part of Georgia’s Right to Work Law
July 13, 2016 | Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
NLRB Hits Ceiling in Continual Push to Expand Scope of Protected Concerted Activity
July 6, 2016 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Fifth Circuit Agrees NLRB Micro-Unit Test Here to Stay
June 9, 2016 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Are Permanent Replacements Permanent Anymore?
June 3, 2016 | National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
NLRB Defends Attempt to Encroach on Tribal Sovereignty
May 27, 2016 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
AFL-CIO to Challenge West Virginia Right to Work Law
May 10, 2016 | Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
GOP Moves to Block New Persuader Rule
April 18, 2016 | Union Organizing, Labor Relations
‘Tis The Season: Unions Continue To Spend Significant Amounts Of Employees’ Dues Money On Political Causes
April 7, 2016 | Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
11th Circuit Overturns NLRB: Finds Atlanta-area Stagehands are Independent Contractors
February 4, 2016 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
NLRB’s New Joint-Employer Standard To Be Put To The Test In Federal Court
January 26, 2016 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Browning-Ferris “All In” On Joint Employer Battle With NLRB
January 15, 2016 | Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Another One Bites the Dust: NLRB Invalidates Another Widely-Used Personnel Policy
January 5, 2016 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Arbitration Agreement “Take Two”: Fifth Circuit Refuses to Revisit D.R. Horton in Murphy Oil Case
October 29, 2015 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Another NLRB Flip-Flop in the Works: Unions Seek to Organize College and University Graduate Assistants
October 28, 2015 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
When Will the Other Shoe Drop? NLRB May Hand Down Second Blow after Browning-Ferris
September 30, 2015 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Employer Dinged for Unlawful Interrogation and Confiscating Union Literature Immediately Following Break Period; Vindicated for Simultaneous Leafletting
September 10, 2015 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
The Hits Keep On Coming: NLRB Ruling Makes It Easier For Unions To Establish “Joint-Employers” Under The NLRA
August 31, 2015 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
NLRB Reaches Agreement With The Republic Of Colombia To Educate Colombian Citizens On The NLRA
June 16, 2015 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
WTF? NLRB’s OK with “Cut the Crap?"
June 4, 2015 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
NO PIN POLICY VIOLATES NLRA
May 7, 2015 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
NLRB Scrutiny Of Employer Handbook Policies Continues With ALJ Ruling Against T-Mobile
March 24, 2015 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
A New Frontier for Right-to-Work Laws?
January 26, 2015 | Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Amazon Settlement with NLRB a Reminder for Employers -- "Confidential" Wage Policies Violate the NLRA
November 25, 2014 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
NLRB Decides Not to Risk Its D.R. Horton Decision
July 22, 2014 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
NLRB Again Overturns Discharge Of Employee Who Engaged In A Profanity-Laced Argument With A Manager In Front Of Customers
June 18, 2014 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Some Hope for Employers? Limits on Alan Ritchey Discretionary Discipline Bargaining Obligation Applied by NLRB
June 13, 2014 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Reality vs. “Objectivity” – The NLRB’s Use of Atlantic Steel to Sanction a Coarsening of the Workplace
June 11, 2014 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
NLRB invites briefs in Northwestern football case
May 12, 2014 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
NLRB Continues To Impose Expansive Penalties On Employers
April 29, 2014 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
For Their Eyes Only: Northwestern to Limit Media Access at Union Polling Location
April 24, 2014 | National Labor Relations Board, Union Organizing, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Northwestern Election Kicks Off This Friday
April 23, 2014 | National Labor Relations Board, Union Organizing, Labor Relations
NLRB DR Horton Rehearing Denied
April 17, 2014 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Northwestern Union Election Date Set
April 3, 2014 | National Labor Relations Board, Union Organizing, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
BTLabor Relations Blogger & Attorney Fields Questions on College Football Players Union Ruling
March 28, 2014 | National Labor Relations Board, Union Organizing, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
NLRB Directs Election at Northwestern – Scholarship Football Players are Employees
March 26, 2014 | National Labor Relations Board, Union Organizing, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
NLRB Chairman signals willingness to reverse Register Guard decision
March 24, 2014 | National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Law on Unionization of Home Care Workers Continues to Shift
March 20, 2014 | Labor Relations, Unions and Union Membership
New Michigan Right to Work Lawsuit Filed After MEA Threatens to Send Teacher to Collections for Failing to Pay Dues
March 10, 2014 | State Labor Laws, Labor Relations
A “Hail Mary”? Northwestern Student-Athletes File Union Petition with the NLRB
January 29, 2014 | National Labor Relations Board, Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
Employee’s Complaint About Union Officials Watching Porn is Deemed “Human Imperfection” But Not Grounds for Retaliation
January 15, 2014 | Unions and Union Membership, Labor Relations
No Gossiping Rule Violates NLRA
December 16, 2013 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Seventh Circuit Rules Salary Payments Violate the Labor Management Relations Act
November 6, 2013 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Decertification 101
September 12, 2013 | Union Organizing, Labor Relations
Associate in Small Law Firm Meets NLRA Definition of Supervisor
June 6, 2013 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
Court Overturns NLRB Decision in Stella D’Oro Biscuit Co. v. NLRB
April 1, 2013 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
NLRB Lightens Grip on At-Will Language
March 12, 2013 | National Labor Relations Board, Labor Relations
RELATED PRACTICE AREAS
Subscribe
Do you want to receive more valuable insights directly in your inbox? Visit our subscription center and let us know what you're interested in learning more about.
View Subscription Center