The Supreme Court recently granted certiorari in Navarro v. Encino Motorcars, LLC, after the Ninth Circuit found that the FLSA exemption for overtime pay does not apply to car dealership service advisors. The relevant FLSA exemption applies to “any salesman, partsman, or mechanic primarily engaged in selling or servicing automobiles.” Service advisors diagnose vehicle service needs and suggest additional services for the maintenance of vehicles. They are paid on a commission basis only, and receive neither an hourly wage nor a salary. Car dealerships have for years relied on the FLSA language and a comprehensive set of case law establishing service advisors’ exemption from overtime pay. In fact, the Ninth Circuit is the first court, state or federal, to find that the exemption does not apply to service advisors. The Ninth Circuit focused its analysis on the grammatical interpretation of the FLSA exemption—namely, whether both verb clauses (selling or servicing) apply to all three subjects (salesman, partsman or mechanic). Writing for the Ninth Circuit, Judge Graber found that only those employees who sell cars are salesman and only those who personally service vehicles are mechanics or partsman. The language of the FLSA, according to Judge Graber, does not logically allow the interpretation that all verb clauses apply to all subjects; therefore, it cannot be said that the exemption applies to a service advisor who is, essentially, a salesman engaged in servicing cars. After intense grammatical foreplay, the Ninth Circuit’s decision was ultimately based on its interpretation of the Department of Labor’s regulatory definitions, which it argued are in line with the Ninth Circuit’s view. While the Ninth Circuit found the Department of Labor’s narrow definitions to be reasonable, the Fourth Circuit disagreed in its 2004 case analyzing the same exemption and definitions. The Fourth Circuit found the DOL’s narrow definitions to be unreasonable and instead held that the exemptions apply to anyone in the general business of selling or servicing cars, which includes service advisors. The Fourth Circuit’s interpretation stands for the proposition that the limitations of selling or servicing cars apply to all three types of employees. In other words, the ordinary construction of a list of subjects (salesman, partsman or mechanic) followed by a list of verbs (selling or servicing) is that each subject is linked to each verb. The Ninth Circuit addressed this point and found it to be blatantly incorrect and in contravention of the DOL’s statutory definitions. The Ninth Circuit attempted to emphasize this point with the following hypothetical: “if my dogs or cats are barking or meowing, then I know that they need be let out.” It explained that, in the Fourth Circuit’s grammatical interpretation, that phrase would include a meowing dog and a barking cat. Most English speakers would make the logical conclusion that the implicit limitations of the phrase refer only to a barking dog and meowing cat. According to the Ninth Circuit, this analytical framework is equally applicable to the FLSA exemption and leads to the conclusion that service advisors are not exempt employees. Grammatical intricacies aside, the Ninth Circuit’s decision rejecting the applicability of the exemption may have far-reaching implications for a workforce comprised of more than 50,000 service advisors. If allowed to stand, the decision will require restructuring of what has been a widely accepted and settled compensation practice in the nation’s car dealership industry.
Meowing Dogs and Barking Cats: Supreme Court Grants Certiorari to Determine Service Advisors’ Eligibility for Overtime Pay
RELATED ARTICLES
Use Your Noodle: Assistant Manager Sues Over COVID-19 Related Termination
September 11, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law
NY Labor Law Watchdog Hit With COVID-19 Overtime Lawsuit Of Its Own
July 30, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law, Fair Labor Standards Act
COVID-19 False Alarm Triggers Tipped Worker Collective Action
July 23, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law
DOL Delivers a Five-Pack of Wage and Hour Opinion Letters
June 30, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law
Here’s a Tip – Restaurant Workers Allege Wage and Hour Violations Amid COVID-19 Pandemic
June 26, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law
Use Your Noodle: Assistant Manager Sues Over COVID-19 Related Termination
September 11, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law
NY Labor Law Watchdog Hit With COVID-19 Overtime Lawsuit Of Its Own
July 30, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law, Fair Labor Standards Act
COVID-19 False Alarm Triggers Tipped Worker Collective Action
July 23, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law
DOL Delivers a Five-Pack of Wage and Hour Opinion Letters
June 30, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law
Here’s a Tip – Restaurant Workers Allege Wage and Hour Violations Amid COVID-19 Pandemic
June 26, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law
As Businesses Reopen, DOL Allows Premium Payments Under the Fluctuating Workweek Method
May 22, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law, Fair Labor Standards Act, Department of Labor
Court Scorches Employer, Upholds Class Arbitration Decision
April 24, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law, Fair Labor Standards Act
Shutting the Gate: Temporary Worker Excluded From FLSA Collective Action
April 23, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law, Fair Labor Standards Act
Salaried-Basis Employees in the World of Temporary COVID-19 Furloughs
April 3, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law, Fair Labor Standards Act, Department of Labor
Bonus! DOL Opinion Letters Clarify Regular Rate Calculation for Workplace Perks
March 30, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law
Employer’s Perseverance Pays Off As District Court Decertifies Disinterested Collective
March 6, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law, Fair Labor Standards Act
No FLSA Friend Requests: Employees With Arbitration Agreements Can’t Get Notice
January 29, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law, Fair Labor Standards Act
New Joint Employment Rule: DOL Clarifies Standard For Liability Under the FLSA
January 17, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law, Fair Labor Standards Act
Third Circuit Schools District Court on Workplace Class Certification
January 8, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law, Fair Labor Standards Act
New DOL Rule Allows Employers to Offer Perks Without Affecting Regular Pay Rate
December 20, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Fair Labor Standards Act
Proposed New Overtime Rule Would Affect Fluctuating Workweek Employees
November 5, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law
No E For Effort: FLSA Conditional Certification Fails Without Supporting Evidence
October 23, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Fair Labor Standards Act
Café Managers’ Second Attempt At Conditional Certification Fails
October 22, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Fair Labor Standards Act
No Right, Just Rules: Court Lacks Jurisdiction Over Steakhouse Managers’ Claims
October 3, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Fair Labor Standards Act
The FLSA Protects Colorado’s Recreational Cannabis Workers
September 25, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Fair Labor Standards Act
Another Court Declines to Defer to DOL Guidance on 20 Percent Rule
August 22, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Employment Lessons
Don’t Fall Asleep on DOL’s New Guidance for Time Truck Drivers Spend in Sleeper Berth
August 1, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Employment Lessons
Recent DOL Guidance Not Entitled to Deference Post-Kisor
July 10, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Employment Lessons
DOL Proposes Long-Awaited New Minimum Salary for Overtime Exemption
March 11, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Fair Labor Standards Act
Common Sense Prevails in California Wage Victory, Falters in PAGA Action
August 15, 2018 | Employment Lessons, Currents - Employment Law
F is for Fluctuate: Overtime Pay And The Fluctuating Workweek (WTH is FWW?)
July 27, 2018 | Letter of the Law, Currents - Employment Law
Will There Be An Epic Backlash?
June 27, 2018 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Supreme Court Watch, Currents - Employment Law
Philadelphia U. S. District Court Determines Uber Drivers Are Independent Contractors
April 23, 2018 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
DOL Issues New Opinion Letters on Wage and Hour Issues – Compensability of Health-Related Rest Breaks
April 18, 2018 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Know Before You Go: Does the DOL’s New PAID Program Pay Off For Employers?
April 16, 2018 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
What’s Old Is New Again: DOL Resurrects Advisory Opinion Letters
January 16, 2018 | Employment Lessons, Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
The DOL Just Flipped Its Position on Paying Interns
January 10, 2018 | Employment Lessons, Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
As Predicted, DOL Proposes Changes to Tip Pool Rule
December 29, 2017 | Employment Discrimination, Employment Lessons, Currents - Employment Law
Second Circuit Holds that Hearst Interns are not Employees
December 12, 2017 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Holiday Road – Avoiding Potholes in Holiday Parties
December 4, 2017 | Employment Lessons, Currents - Employment Law
House Passes Bill to Legalize Comp Time in the Private Sector
May 8, 2017 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Lesson: Don’t Underestimate Court’s Ability to Change Its Mind
April 6, 2017 | Employment Lessons, Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Trump Administration Quick Hitters: Acting EEOC Chair Named, Chief of Staff Requests Regulation Freeze, and DOJ Requests Delay in Fifth Circuit Appeal of OT Rule
January 30, 2017 | High Stakes Employment Issues, Currents - Employment Law
The DOL’s Final Rule on Life Support?
December 30, 2016 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
December 1 Overtime Rule Blocked
November 22, 2016 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Using an Employee’s Social Media Posts to Prove Laziness? Think Again
November 21, 2016 | Employment Lessons, Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
The World According to Trump: Revenge of the Pen – Overturning Obama’s Executive Orders and Employment Policies
November 16, 2016 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
The World According to Trump: A Prologue
November 14, 2016 | High Stakes Employment Issues, Currents - Employment Law
Department of Labor to Issue Finalized White Collar Exemption Rule on Wednesday, May 18
May 17, 2016 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
11th Hour Questions about DOL’s Overtime Rules
April 19, 2016 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Friend or Foe?: Terminated HR Director Can Bring Retaliation Case, Court Says
January 4, 2016 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Employees May Soon Have Something To Lose In FLSA Lawsuits
August 13, 2015 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
DOL FINALLY UNVEILS PROPOSED GUIDANCE AFFECTING OVERTIME
June 30, 2015 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Employers Won’t “Like” Ruling Allowing Class Action Notifications via Social Media
May 6, 2015 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
Not So Fast: Parties Cannot Impose Confidentiality Restrictions on Judicially Approved FLSA Settlements
January 29, 2015 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
X-Rays Shipped Out of State Help Employee Keep Issue of FLSA Coverage Alive
January 26, 2015 | Letter of the Law, Currents - Employment Law
Unanimous Supreme Court Denies Compensation for Time Spent in Security Checks
December 11, 2014 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Don’t Disregard Your Employees’ Rights, Even If They’re Strippers
November 19, 2014 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
An Employer’s Liability Under The FLSA Can Be High
July 31, 2014 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Collective and Class Actions: Interns, Assistant Managers – and their Lawyers!
July 18, 2014 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Letter of the Law, Currents - Employment Law
Revisiting Judicial Approval of Fair Labor Standards Act Settlements
June 19, 2014 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Apple Employees Survive Summary Judgment in FLSA Bag Check Class Action
June 4, 2014 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
UNPAID INTERNS STRIKE AGAIN – CLASS OF 3000 EX-WARNER INTERNS APPROVED FOR WAGE AND HOUR CASE
May 19, 2014 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Act One in Unpaid Intern Appeal Has Begun
April 8, 2014 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Supreme Court Rules That Donning And Doffing Time May Not Be Compensable
January 29, 2014 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Commission or Piece-Rate? The Distinction Is Significant for FLSA Purposes
November 22, 2013 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Federal Court Denies Class Certification, Preemptively Denies FLSA Collective Action – Class Members’ Experiences Too Varied
October 15, 2013 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Home Health Care Workers Now Protected Under the FLSA
September 18, 2013 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Judicial Approval No More? The Days of Judicially Scrutinized FLSA Settlements May Be Drawing To a Close
March 14, 2013 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
U.S. Supreme Court Agrees to Clarify FLSA’s Exemption for Donning and Doffing Time
February 21, 2013 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
The FLSA Also Requires Employers To Provide Private Lactation Break Rooms
February 1, 2013 | Employee Health Issues, Currents - Employment Law
8th Circuit Upholds Class Waivers in FLSA Cases
January 9, 2013 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
When Numbers Count
December 19, 2012 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Losing A Fair Labor Standards Act Lawsuit Can Be Costly
November 8, 2012 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Federal Court In Washington Rules That Sales Agent Is A Contractor, Not An Employee
September 28, 2012 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
RELATED PRACTICE AREAS
Subscribe
Do you want to receive more valuable insights directly in your inbox? Visit our subscription center and let us know what you're interested in learning more about.
View Subscription Center