Earlier in August, we issued an Alert detailing continued hostility to arbitration of employment disputes in some corners of the California state courts, even following the U.S. Supreme Court decisions in Stolt-Nielsen v. AnimalFeeds Internat. Corp., __ U.S. __ [130 S.Ct. 1758] (2010) (“Stolt-Nielsen”) and AT&T Mobility LLC v. Concepcion, 563 U.S. __, 131 S.Ct. 1740 (2011) (“Concepcion”). On August 13, 2012, yet another California Court of Appeal weighed into the fray, but provided little clarity.
The California Court of Appeal decision in Truly Nolen of America v. Superior Court, Cal. App. 4th No. D060519 (2012) (“Truly Nolen”), underscores the unsettled state of the law. The Truly Nolen court recognized that the holding and reasoning of Stolt-Nielsen and Concepcion call into question the validity of several prior California Supreme Court decisions involving arbitration, including Gentry v. Superior Court, 42 Cal.4th 443 (2007) (“Gentry”). However, the Truly Nolen Court concluded that while Concepcion’s rationale undermines the holding of Gentry, it did not directly overrule it. Thus, the Court concluded that in the absence of California Supreme Court authority to the contrary, Gentry’s limitations on arbitration must still be applied. The Court then held that the trial court erred because it did not require the employees to provide a “specific, individualized, and precise” analysis demonstrating how their claims met Gentry’s four-factor test. Then, in a surprising turn, the Court’s remand also directed the trial court to resolve a foundational issue of whether the parties had an implied agreement to submit to class-action arbitration. This direction suggests a reluctance to apply Stolt-Nielsen’s holding that precludes class-action arbitration absent the parties’ express agreement. Thus, Truly Nolen reflects California courts’ schizophrenic view of arbitration of employment disputes. The Court laid the foundation for the Supreme Court to overrule the restrictions imposed by Gentry while at the same time opening a new avenue of attack on such provisions notwithstanding the U.S. Supreme Court holding in Stolt-Nielsen. One thing is certain: there is more to come.Another California Court of Appeal Struggles to Come To Grips with Arbitration
RELATED ARTICLES
California Supreme Court Adds New Employer Obligations for Meal and Rest Breaks
May 26, 2022 | Currents - Employment Law
Biden Bans Mandatory Arbitration for Sexual Harassment and Assault Claims
March 4, 2022 | Currents - Employment Law
In a Blow to the Transportation Industry, Ninth Circuit Overturns AB 5 Injunction
April 30, 2021 | Currents - Employment Law
California Adopts New Exemptions from AB 5 Independent Contractor Classification
September 9, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law
Motorin’: CAFA Removal Upheld, California Wage and Hour Class Action Dismissed
August 26, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law, Workplace Culture and Conduct, Employment Lessons
California Supreme Court Adds New Employer Obligations for Meal and Rest Breaks
May 26, 2022 | Currents - Employment Law
Biden Bans Mandatory Arbitration for Sexual Harassment and Assault Claims
March 4, 2022 | Currents - Employment Law
In a Blow to the Transportation Industry, Ninth Circuit Overturns AB 5 Injunction
April 30, 2021 | Currents - Employment Law
California Adopts New Exemptions from AB 5 Independent Contractor Classification
September 9, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law
Motorin’: CAFA Removal Upheld, California Wage and Hour Class Action Dismissed
August 26, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law, Workplace Culture and Conduct, Employment Lessons
Outbreak of COVID-19 Public Nuisance Cases Continues
August 7, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law, Employee Health Issues
Public Nuisance Claims Emerge In COVID-19 Workplace Litigation Filings
June 19, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law, Employee Health Issues
COVID-19 Related Workplace Litigation Picks Up Steam
June 12, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law, Employee Health Issues
Illinois Federal Court Rejects Arbitration of BIPA Class Action
June 10, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law
Brain Freeze: California Federal Court Rejects Ice Cream Shop’s CAFA Removal
May 29, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law
California Creates Workers’ Compensation Presumption of Coverage for COVID-19 Illnesses
May 8, 2020 | Currents - Employment Law, Employee Health Issues
California Appellate Court Finds Open-Ended Pay-When-Paid Clause Unenforceable
May 1, 2020 | Construction Law, Contracts
California's Law Barring Arbitration Won't Go Into Effect January 1
December 31, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law
California Cracks Down on Independent Contractor Status in Gig Economy
September 19, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Employment Lessons
Long Road Ahead As Congress Begins Chipping Away At Workplace Arbitration
September 19, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Employment Lessons
California Supreme Court Rejects Workplace Arbitration Agreement
September 13, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Employment Lessons
California Court Rejects Motion To Arbitrate PAGA Claim Under State Labor Code
August 16, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Employment Lessons
Class Arbitrability is a Decision for the Court, Not the Arbitrator
July 24, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, High Stakes Employment Issues
Federal De Minimis Rule Does Not Apply To California State Wage and Hour Claims
July 11, 2019 | Currents - Employment Law, Employment Lessons
Common Sense Prevails in California Wage Victory, Falters in PAGA Action
August 15, 2018 | Employment Lessons, Currents - Employment Law
Round Up: Court Rules Rounding Payroll System Permissible Even When (a slight) Majority of Employees Lose Time
June 29, 2018 | Employment Lessons, Currents - Employment Law
California Supreme Court Ruling to Give More Workers Employee Status
May 2, 2018 | Employment Lessons, Currents - Employment Law
ICE Raids on 7-Eleven Franchise Stores Result in 21 Arrests
January 12, 2018 | Employment Lessons, High Stakes Employment Issues, Currents - Employment Law
On Second Thought … State Supreme Court Questions Key Noncompete Drafting Strategy
December 18, 2017 | Non-competes and Trade Secrets, Currents - Employment Law
R-E-S-P-E-C-T in the Workplace? The EEOC Becomes Trainer-in-Chief
October 6, 2017 | EEOC, Workplace Culture and Conduct, Currents - Employment Law
California Bill Placing Restrictions on Employer Immigration Worksite Raids Awaits Governor’s Signature
September 29, 2017 | Employment Lessons, Currents - Employment Law
California Dreaming: Court Upholds Restrictions in Employment Agreement, Bars Use of Confidential Information
September 12, 2017 | Non-competes and Trade Secrets, Currents - Employment Law
Trump-Era Immigration Worksite Raid Threats May Bring New Requirements for California Employers
June 2, 2017 | Employment Lessons, Currents - Employment Law
California Supreme Court Throws Down the Gauntlet on Arbitration Waivers
April 24, 2017 | Employment Lessons, Currents - Employment Law
Fifth Circuit Triples Down on the Legality of Class Action Waivers in Arbitration Agreements
August 15, 2016 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
Employer’s Delay Results in Waiver of Arbitration
May 14, 2016 | Employment Lessons, Currents - Employment Law
Ok...Are You Sitting Down?
April 5, 2016 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
California Employee Arbitration Bill Vetoed
October 15, 2015 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
Altering Arbitration: Sakkab v. Luxottica Retail North America
October 8, 2015 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Man Bites Dog: Court Vacates Arbitration Award Against Sexual Harasser
September 2, 2015 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
California Strikes Again! Senate ‘OKs’ Bill Limiting Employment Arbitration
August 28, 2015 | Employment Lessons, Currents - Employment Law
Federal Court Allows Arbitration After Employer’s Nine-Month Delay
August 18, 2015 | Employment Lessons, Currents - Employment Law
Not so Fast: 'No-Rehire' Clauses Could be a Restraint on Trade
April 28, 2015 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
Are You Relying on Electronic Signatures for Employment Documents?
January 30, 2015 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
Supreme Court Leaves California’s Carve-Out for PAGA Wage-and-Hour Representative Actions Intact
January 23, 2015 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
On Break, But Still on Call: “On Call” Rest Breaks are Permissible Under California Law
January 9, 2015 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
California Class Action an Occasion for All Employers to Review Vacation Practices
January 5, 2015 | Letter of the Law, Currents - Employment Law
California Governor Signs Bills Impacting California Wage Suits
August 22, 2014 | Employment Discrimination, Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Ninth Circuit FAAAA Meal and Rest Period Preemption Decision Appealed
August 8, 2014 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Federal Appellate Court Rules That Arbitration of Class Action Claims Is An Issue For Courts And Not Arbitrators To Decide
August 4, 2014 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
9th Circuit Rules that the FAAAA Does Not Preempt California Meal and Rest Period Laws
July 14, 2014 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
New California Employment Laws Take Effect on July 1, 2014—Increased Minimum Wage, Expanded Paid Family Leave and Further Limits on Background Checks
July 1, 2014 | Employee Health Issues, Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
Fifth Circuit Denies NLRB’s Rehearing Request on Class Action Waivers; NLRB Likely to Continue Ignoring Fifth (and Other) Circuit Court Rulings
April 21, 2014 | Traditional Labor, Currents - Employment Law
Against the Anchorman: California Court of Appeal Deems Hiring Young, Female Weather Anchors a Protected Exercise of Free Speech
January 9, 2014 | Employment Discrimination, Currents - Employment Law
California Court of Appeals Overturns Superior Court Denial of Class Certification
December 6, 2013 | Traditional Labor, Currents - Employment Law
Governor Would Like Massachusetts to Join California As a Non-Noncompete State
September 16, 2013 | Non-competes and Trade Secrets, Currents - Employment Law
California Appeals Court Approves Rounding of Employee Time
November 1, 2012 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
California Passes Law to Regulate Access to Employees’ Social Media Accounts
October 4, 2012 | Social Media and Technology, Currents - Employment Law
California Governor Signs Law Prohibiting Explicit Mutual Wage Agreements
October 3, 2012 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
California Creates First State-Run Retirement Plan for Private Sector Employees
October 2, 2012 | Traditional Labor, Currents - Employment Law
California Supreme Court to Review Class Action Arbitration Waivers in Employment Agreements
September 25, 2012 | Traditional Labor, Currents - Employment Law
Class Arbitration Prohibited if Not Authorized in Agreement
September 7, 2012 | Fair Labor Standards Act, Currents - Employment Law
RELATED PRACTICE AREAS
Subscribe
Do you want to receive more valuable insights directly in your inbox? Visit our subscription center and let us know what you're interested in learning more about.
View Subscription Center